My P4P top 10 list

[Caught Square]

Let's compare Rigo and Walters...

Age: Rigo is old and looked shot in his last fight, Walters is just entering his prime.

Chin: Rigo gets knocked down left and right by everyone like a ragdoll, from Cordoba to Donaire to Amagasa, while Walters ate a heavier Donaire's punches like he had some Carl Froch jaw.

Power: Rigo's power is okay. Walters' power is destructive.

Resume: Rigo got only 15 fights and his only good win was a decision against Donaire, while getting knocked down in the process. Walters crushed and stopped Donaire easily and he beat Marriaga, a dangerous opponent, in his last fight.

Walters is, simply put, better than Rigo.

Lol you have to be trolling. Rigo looked good as ever in his last fight, look at the size of the guy he was fighting, he switched off and got dropped, it happens. Rigo dominated every other round and broke his face. Literally.

I'm pretty sure Walters has been dropped by lesser guys but no footage saves him.

Power doesn't determine whether someone ranks higher p4p. Anyway, Walters is much bigger than most of his opponents, can't even make 126 anyone and Rigo is outweighed by almost everyone he fights yet still makes them shook.

As far as resume it's not like Rigo has fought Gary Russell-esque opposition besides Donaire. I think his resume is slept on tbh. Donaire is his only VERY good win but he has some solid wins over the likes of Agbeko and Cordoba who were high ranked guys at 122.

I don't know why you made this Rigo vs Walters, there's numerous guys on your list Rigo should be above.

[Rokozoko]

Lol you have to be trolling. Rigo looked good as ever in his last fight, look at the size of the guy he was fighting, he switched off and got dropped, it happens. Rigo dominated every other round and broke his face. Literally.

I'm pretty sure Walters has been dropped by lesser guys but no footage saves him.

Power doesn't determine whether someone ranks higher p4p. Anyway, Walters is much bigger than most of his opponents, can't even make 126 anyone and Rigo is outweighed by almost everyone he fights yet still makes them shook.

As far as resume it's not like Rigo has fought Gary Russell-esque opposition besides Donaire. I think his resume is slept on tbh. Donaire is his only VERY good win but he has some solid wins over the likes of Agbeko and Cordoba who were high ranked guys at 122.

I don't know why you made this Rigo vs Walters, there's numerous guys on your list Rigo should be above.

Those were some pretty lame arguments. But yeah, the old, small, glass-jawed Rigo just got NOTHING on Walters and this thread shouldn't be about Rigo, he is not relevant in a top 10 P4P list, he is probably inside the top 15-20, though. I just made this thread to keep that a separate debate:

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=681530

[BrometheusBob.]

P4P top 10:
1 - Floyd Mayweather
2 - Andre Ward
3 - Wladimir Klitschko
4 - Manny Pacquiao
5 - Sergey Kovalev
6 - James DeGale
7 - Alexander Povetkin
8 - Timothy Bradley
9 - Nicholas Walters
10 - Deontay Wilder

What I like about numbers 6-10 is that my laughter increased in intensity after each name I read.

[Rokozoko]

What I like about numbers 6-10 is that my laughter increased in intensity after each name I read.

The truth can be funny sometimes, but as I stated earlier in the thread, Gonzales should probably be #10 instead of Wilder.