Where is Calzaghe P4P?

[AintGottaClue]

no less then 5, pac,barrera,winky, floyd can be put in front of him

[Derranged]

I would've liked to see the look on James TOney's face after watching this fight after all that **** he was talkin about JOE

[JoartCC]

Honestly, those saying that Cali should be top 4 p4p is either in denial or dumb. Cali has beaten a green Lacy, that's all. If he intends to be one of the elite of the elites, he better prove 2-3 more times by beating top fighters.

PBF
PAC
Wright
Barrera
Hatton
Taylor
Castillo
Tarver
CALI


Cali has to beat more top fighters to go up.

[paul750]

Green Lacy my ass. no one was saying that before the fight.

[JoartCC]

Green Lacy my ass. no one was saying that before the fight.

Ok. Let's take that argument out and say that he beat a prime Lacy.

But if you look at it. It's just one win against a top fighter. Do you admit that winning a single fight against a somebody catapults you at the top that easy? Cmon! You gotta admit Cali has to prove more if he wants to climb the top.

There's taylor and Wright or if he wants it tarver.

2-3 more wins against top fighters and he's in the top 5 easy.

Do we agree on that?

[paul750]

I agree he has to fight more good fighters to truly be considered a great fighter, but i still think on his performance last night he should be in the top ten p4p easily.

[JoartCC]

I agree he has to fight more good fighters to truly be considered a great fighter, but i still think on his performance last night he should be in the top ten p4p easily.

I'm not contesting that his win over Lacy catapults him into the top 10 p4p. But if you look at the reality of it. One big will will simply catapult him into the backend of the elite list (8-10), nothing more.

As long as he keeps on winning against top fighters, of course he has the chance to be top 3 p4p easy.

There's Wright and Taylor or Tarver. He needs more big wins.

[Bozo_no no]

Beating Jones, who was clearly ranked #1 at the time moved Tarver to 8th if he was lucky. Some didn't have him in at all.

The majority of pound for pound lists as of late did not even have Lacy on them.

How does that vault Joe into the top ten?

Makes no sense.

[scap]

Beating Jones, who was clearly ranked #1 at the time moved Tarver to 8th if he was lucky. Some didn't have him in at all.

The majority of pound for pound lists as of late did not even have Lacy on them.

How does that vault Joe into the top ten?

Makes no sense.

Im not gonna get carried away and say that Joe is #3 or some **** like that but you think it would be ridculous to say he is #10 or 9?

[Bozo_no no]

Im not gonna get carried away and say that Joe is #3 or some **** like that but you think it would be to say he is #10 or 9?

Ridculous? No. But a stretch imo. If Lacy had been universally on most top ten pound for pound list then I could see it, but when Tarver destroyed the #1 guy by knock out, he only moved in and hovered around 8 - 10.