Where is Calzaghe P4P?

[GunStar]

GTFOOH LOL

Taylor #4? Really... and what has he done other than won 2 fights by a very, very, f'ing very close desisions over a 40+ year old...?

Castillo? Good one... Someone who has 3 losses in his last 12 fights

Wright #1? Because he embarassed Trini..? Well, Lacy completely outclassed Lacy, and?

Oh.. I know...... It's the American, anti-European factor again, that's what it is... the bias view got into your head

That 40 years old will beat any version of Cal. When Taylor beat Hopkins he was the #1 P4P guy. Taylor should be in top 3, not Cal with his win against Lacy.

[supaduck]

Currently i'd rank joe at about 7. He proved a hell of a lot of people wrong by dominating the fight he was expected to lose easily.

[mECHsLAVE]

I think he's as high as #5, and no lower than #8.

[paul750]

Well Lacy was very highly thought of before the fight, and he was in many peoples p4p lists, so after a performance like that Calzaghe is easily top ten, maybe even top 5.

[Kimmy]

I think he's as high as #5, and no lower than #8.

I agree with this!

[OptimusWolf]

I think that list is about right SL, although maybe not Tarvernot sure who i'd replace him with though to be honest, too many losing at the moment!

[T to the T]

Top 5 being realistic IMO, with Hatton, Mayweather, Tarver and maybe Taylor just in front of him...

[morancito]

The top 4 are

1 Wright
2 Pac
3 Floyd
4 Barrera

That is clear, at least for me. It gets interesting though in the next 6. In no particular order:

R Marquez
Castillo
Taylor
Tarver
Hatton
Calzaghe

[mECHsLAVE]

Top 5 being realistic IMO, with Hatton, Mayweather, Tarver and maybe Taylor just in front of him...

Pac in front of him, too. But I think I'd put Tarver behind him IMHO. I think it's very possible that Calzaghe would have beaten the version of Johnson and Jones that Tarver beat, if he was as up for those fights as he was for Lacy.

[T to the T]

Pac in front of him, too. But I think I'd put Tarver behind him IMHO. I think it's very possible that Calzaghe would have beaten the version of Johnson and Jones that Tarver beat, if he was as up for those fights as he was for Lacy.

It's all debatable as that's what P4P is but JC is definately Top 5 and no lower IMO