Who are the current active fighters you would consider "ATG'S?"

[Brandish]

you think those guys are ATG, but not manny. and even if he manny was a 5 division champ, that would make him ATG... hello wake up dude, you seem to think paper belts mean everything. in 20 years we will look at these dudes resumes, forget about the weights, how old they were, how good they looked before. we will see HOF name after HOF name after HOF name. manny's victories and rise to the top of the sport is what make him great. you are in denial.... just admit it. its a fact that those guys are ATG.

Your way too emotional. My standards are different from your standards so we will never agree on manny being an ATG.


As I have explained before manny is a hofer but he is not made of ATG stuff.

Look at who he beat for his titles and look at who Floyd beat. It's no comparison.

Floyd is ATG #1 at 130 manny is ATG at no weight class. He has 6 defenses of his 5 titles that's a good managed career.

[Brandish]

You have no idea what your talking about,
1. didnt say anything about 118,,, its 112,,, and yes manny was a belt there

2. he beat lineal champs barrera and hatton and won both times in devastating fashion, also beat the 130 champ jmm in the 2nd fight


3. Yes some where paper titles, but every fighter has those,,, manny beating diaz and margs for belts were kinda meaningless, just like when floyd beat gatti,,

4. If you dont think manny is an ATG, then your really DKSAB,

Ok so what I gathered is that you just like manny and want him to be an ATG. But based on what you just wrote beAting Barrera, gaston, and morales, do not make you an ATG. You need your whole career to measure out, not just a few titles you never defended of weak champs.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Ok so what I gathered is that you just like manny and want him to be an ATG. But based on what you just wrote beAting Barrera, gaston, and morales, do not make you an ATG. You need your whole career to measure out, not just a few titles you never defended of weak champs.

your so dumb,,, if you have larryX and sugarmosely on the same side, then you know you are wrong.....

i wont discuss it any further,, if you dont think manny is ATG, then more power to you, but your an idiot

[sugarsmosley]

Your way too emotional. My standards are different from your standards so we will never agree on manny being an ATG.


As I have explained before manny is a hofer but he is not made of ATG stuff.

Look at who he beat for his titles and look at who Floyd beat. It's no comparison.

Floyd is ATG #1 at 130 manny is ATG at no weight class. He has 6 defenses of his 5 titles that's a good managed career.

im emotional? ..... dude you're trying to turn this thread into floyd vs. manny. who the fck is comparing those two dudes to each other? is this thread called whos great pac or may? no it's not. facts are that you cant accept facts are in denial.... you think shane is an ATG but not pac... that shows you have a biased agenda and not a true boxing fan..

[BUNGALOWS]

wlad's not an all time great and it was not an honor to witness him.

HAHAHAHA, you so crazy.

[BUNGALOWS]

im emotional? ..... dude you're trying to turn this thread into floyd vs. manny. who the fck is comparing those two dudes to each other? is this thread called whos great pac or may? no it's not. facts are that you cant accept facts are in denial.... you think shane is an ATG but not pac... that shows you have a biased agenda and not a true boxing fan..

Bro, you're talking to Larry's alt. He always does this. Starts a thread giving guys like Manny credit, then busts out his alt to discredit the fighter he doesn't like.

That's his M.O. He has no life whatsoever. It's a way for him to say, "see! I give Manny credit! Then he uses his alt to not give him credit."

So transparent.

[Brandish]

im emotional? ..... dude you're trying to turn this thread into floyd vs. manny. who the fck is comparing those two dudes to each other? is this thread called whos great pac or may? no it's not. facts are that you cant accept facts are in denial.... you think shane is an ATG but not pac... that shows you have a biased agenda and not a true boxing fan..

Typical nean attitude. Lol

[Sosay]

Honestly without reading the comments, I'll say. Pac, Floyd, Hopkins, Klit bros, Marquez, Roy jr, Morales and maybe Mosley.

[croz]

Pac
Mayweather
Cotto
Hopkins
JMM
Wlad
Haye (consider cruiser career)
Bradley (Pac and JMM win, will be bigger as we watch where Ruslan will go)
Froch
Martinez
Ward
RJJ
Toney
Evander - whatever he's doing now

[Larry the boss]

Bro, you're talking to Larry's alt. He always does this. Starts a thread giving guys like Manny credit, then busts out his alt to discredit the fighter he doesn't like.

That's his M.O. He has no life whatsoever. It's a way for him to say, "see! I give Manny credit! Then he uses his alt to not give him credit."

So transparent.

my alt??wtf? go straight to a mod right now and see if it is my alt