Who are the current active fighters you would consider "ATG'S?"

[buckfangs]

Toney not an ATG? funny

[croz]

Your way too emotional. My standards are different from your standards so we will never agree on manny being an ATG.


As I have explained before manny is a hofer but he is not made of ATG stuff.

Look at who he beat for his titles and look at who Floyd beat. It's no comparison.

Floyd is ATG #1 at 130 manny is ATG at no weight class. He has 6 defenses of his 5 titles that's a good managed career.

It's not an argument about who is the better ATG, just who is an ATG. That's a very vague term and open to all kinds of speculation. People often put Braddock down as an ATG for having one good fight, Gatti is also considered an ATG by many and so is Ernie Shavers. An ATG can basically mean anyone who was a top talent or often name in their era, ranking where they stand on ATG lists is another thing entirely.

[Larry the boss]

Pac
Mayweather
Cotto
Hopkins
JMM
Wlad
Haye (consider cruiser career)
Bradley (Pac and JMM win, will be bigger as we watch where Ruslan will go)
Froch
Martinez
Ward
RJJ
Toney
Evander - whatever he's doing now

are you even close to serious??? bradley,froch,martinez,cotto,haye ward are no way in hell atg's

[Sugar Adam Ali]

are you even close to serious??? bradley,froch,martinez,cotto,haye ward are no way in hell atg's

I agree,, those guys are hall of famers,, good champions, and great fighters but not ATGs


People need to realize, the great fighters become HOFers, but an ATG is the best of the HOFers,,, THe best of the Best

[sugarsmosley]

are you even close to serious??? bradley,froch,martinez,cotto,haye ward are no way in hell atg's

lol i was just about to say that but said fck it, its debatable whether or not haye is even a HOF.

[Szef]

PAC and woad are not ATG by my standards

Nobody gives a shit about your standards.

[sugarsmosley]

I agree,, those guys are hall of famers,, good champions, and great fighters but not ATGs


People need to realize, the great fighters become HOFers, but an ATG is the best of the HOFers,,, THe best of the Best

to me it goes good,great,champion,HOF, ATG, Legend, Ali. haha

[Citizen Koba]

Roy Jones, Floyd Mayweather, Manny Pacquaio, and Wladimir Klitschko.

BHop has to be there, his incredible MW run and record breaking longevity make him a lock IMO.

Wlad gets plenty of dislike and I ain't really a fan myself, though I'm old enough to remember Wlad as posterity will; an apparentltly unstoppable machine - Ivan Drago incarnate. Wlads championship reign, record and KO ratio put him amongst the ATGs at HW - posterity will brush over the easy defenses and the hugging as we ignore these things in the great fighters from the past.

Toney, in ways, deserves to belong there, but why isn't he one of the names that comes to my mind immediately? Probably because he never had a prolonged period as the top fighter in any single division. Great as he was, whatever weight he fought at there was always someone better...or at least competitive...the others stood out head and shoulders for a large part of their careers.

[thuggery]

Lomachenko is 400-1 in amateur bouts. he's close

[Weltschmerz]

Wladimir
Pacquiao
Mayweather
Hopkins
James Toney
Roy Jones Jr.

Rigondeaux (no, but consider still)