Originally posted by shade darkar
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Comments Thread For: Pacquiao Admits Mayweather Fight Unlikely Until 2015
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by Evol View Postplease show me where tim, shane and jmm had to break out of their contract just to go sign with top rank in order to get a fight with manny, please show me. And one more thing, was jmm, shane and tim ever in any negotiation with manny and top rank in the first place before they got signed to top rank like how manny and top rank was in negotiation with floyd and golden boy in 2009 then all of a sudden end of 2013 floyd says pac needs to leave arum first. how the phuck is this even the same as what u're trying to justify? LMAO!!!! please show me where jmm, shane, and tim had a negotiation with bob and top rank already before they got signed.
You are trying to make them monumentally different to somehow make floyd's request worse than TR's.
Its really simple.
1. If you didn't have a problem when TR/manny asked for this you shouldn't have a problem when floyd asks for it.
2. If manny/bob's requests to fighters are not roadblocks than niether are floyd's requests.
3. If other fighters can agree to demands to get a big fight manny can do the same.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Evol View Posti cant believe flomo dunn is trying to compare the 2 LOL!! jmm, shane and tim was NEVER i repeat never in any type of negotiation like how manny was with floyd in 09. both teams sat down and negotiate and it didnt work out, years later floyd comes out with manny needs to leave top rank first. how is this the same as shane, jmm and tim??? did all 3 of them had a negotiation with bob and it didnt work out? then bob offer them to come sign with bob and bob will give them a fight with manny?? did this happen???
1. its ok for Bob/Manny to ask for these things because they didn't have previous negotiations for a manny fight? And
2. because there was a previous negotiation in 09 floyd can't ask for the leave the promoter stip in 2012?
If this is what you are saying they are two of the more ridiculous things I've read on NSB in general and from you in particular.
Didn't SHane and JMM have previous negoltiations?
Comment
-
Originally posted by The Big Dunn View PostFloyd said manny had to sign with TMT to ge a fight-this is the same thing Bob/Manny said to the fighters I listed. Niether Bob?manny or floyd specified breaking out of a current contract. That said, JMM and SHane were with GBP and Tim was with another promoter.
You are trying to make them monumentally different to somehow make floyd's request worse than TR's.
Its really simple.
1. If you didn't have a problem when TR/manny asked for this you shouldn't have a problem when floyd asks for it.
2. If manny/bob's requests to fighters are not roadblocks than niether are floyd's requests.
3. If other fighters can agree to demands to get a big fight manny can do the same.
Comment
-
I won't really care if it happens next year, Pacquiao will probably be way over the hill by then, It should have happened in 09. However I actually think that Floyd is a better fighter now than he was in 09 - in fact I would go as far as to say this current version of Floyd would beat a prime Pacquiao.
Comment
-
Originally posted by The Big Dunn View PostSO you are saying:
1. its ok for Bob/Manny to ask for these things because they didn't have previous negotiations for a manny fight? And
2. because there was a previous negotiation in 09 floyd can't ask for the leave the promoter stip in 2012?
Didn't SHane and JMM have previous negoltiations?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Evol View Postidiot dunn please read carefully. im asking u did tim, jmm and shane had a negotiation with top rank in hopes for a fight with manny at the beginning when they were not with top rank yet? did this happen? yes or no?? so how are u trying to compare that with what floyd is asking pac to do? floyd and pac were actually negotiating, ost was the issue, fight didnt happen. years later floyd now comes out with pac needs to leave arum first. so again how is this the same as what u're trying to compare with what jmm, tim and shane had to do??
I am comparing the requests from the a sides in each instance. I am then looking at the b sides actions/responses. I then apply both to the floyd/mnny fight.
I did not say the situations were the same, I said the requests are. You are trying to argue since the situations are not excatly the same the requests are different. we disagree.
Since the first negotitations fell through Manny/Bob have on 3 occasions made non TR fighters sign to TR as a condition of getting a fight with Manny.
Floyd, seeing that fighters were willing to do this and knowing this is a smart way to protect your investment is asking Manny to do this.
If you didn't care then its not a big deal now.
Comment
-
dunn since u said shane, tim, and jmm were actually in negotiation with manny and top rank please tell me what happen in the first negotiation as to why the fight didnt happen?? manny was in negotiation with floyd, cut off date of ost was not agree upon so fight didnt happen. years later ost is not an issue anymore but bob is now? so tell how is this the same as to what u're saying for jmm, shane and tim?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Evol View Postno, im saying what u're trying to compare here is a completely different situation. jmm and shane and tim didnt have a negotiation with bob and manny first and it didnt work out for what ever reasons then years later bob comes out with an offer telling them to leave their promoter and they'll get a fight with manny. im asking did this happen? how are u even trying to justify this as the same?? i can see ur point if jmm, shane and tim were actaully in negotiation with bob and it didnt work out then bob offer them to leave their promoter. if this happen then i can see where u're coming from. with floyd it was ost only then now u have to leave top rank. did this ever happen to shane, jmm and tim??
Since Ive answered your questions please answer this-if manny and floyd both knock the same fighter out in the 3rd round-is one a 3rd round KO and the other not a 3rd round ko because one fight is a 10 round fight and the other a 12 round fight?
Comment
Comment