Who ranks higher? Mayweathe or Calzaghe?

[InSaiyan]

if u count jones jr as an ATG win you have to do it for mayweather with marquez and Oscar.

[LacedUp]

mayweather beat oscar, mosley and marquez...they are atgs are they not?

ATGs or HOFamers?

I don't know if they are ATGs, but Floyd beat all of them past their prime. I'll give a lot of credit for the Marquez win seeing as he's still going strong, similar to Hopkins for Joe.

But Hopkins still > Marquez.

But Mayweather's resume is undoubtedly a lot deeper than Joe's.

[Kuyukut]

How can a cherry picker, ped user and well known ducker can be an atg?

floyd's a fraud!

[InSaiyan]

ATGs or HOFamers?

I don't know if they are ATGs, but Floyd beat all of them past their prime. I'll give a lot of credit for the Marquez win seeing as he's still going strong, similar to Hopkins for Joe.

But Hopkins still > Marquez.

But Mayweather's resume is undoubtedly a lot deeper than Joe's.

i think hopkins, jones, mosley, marquez, delahoya are all atgs.

i just figure, mayweather has a deeper resume, on top of "ATG wins"

[LacedUp]

Roy Jones is an ATG win to Calzaghe fans? They are just as dellusional as Joe was back when he was so happy he was fighting a "legend".

Now, I don't think he is.

But he's similar to Floyd vs Oscar or Sugar Shane.

[LacedUp]

i think hopkins, jones, mosley, marquez, delahoya are all atgs.

i just figure, mayweather has a deeper resume, on top of "ATG wins"

They might be ATGs but they certainly weren't ATG wins. Neither was Joe's win over Jones. IF it had happened ten years earlier, then it would have been a fight.

I just think Floyd lacks that career defining win. His best win name wise is probably an old Oscar, credit wise probably JMM, even though he was really a lightweight.

Joe's wins over Hopkins and Kessler are as good as anything Mayweather has, in terms of prime rivals in their division.

[InSaiyan]

They might be ATGs but they certainly weren't ATG wins. Neither was Joe's win over Jones. IF it had happened ten years earlier, then it would have been a fight.

I just think Floyd lacks that career defining win. His best win name wise is probably an old Oscar, credit wise probably JMM, even though he was really a lightweight.

Joe's wins over Hopkins and Kessler are as good as anything Mayweather has, in terms of prime rivals in their division.

hopkins wasn't prime lol

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Joe has 2 atg wins. Mayweather 0.

You are grasping at straws to have 2,, hopkins is legit roy no, he was a shell of himself

If you count Jones Jr as an ATG win, then you also have to count Oscar.

Oscar is a way better win,,, he at least had a title and handnt been ko'd a bunch of times...

mayweather beat oscar, mosley and marquez...they are atgs are they not?

exactly

[InSaiyan]

Oscar is a way better win,,, he at least had a title and handnt been ko'd a bunch of times...

exactly

basically this. and floyd was way smaller against DLH

[Humean]

I'm a big Calzaghe fan but it is still clearly Mayweather.