Who ranks higher? Mayweathe or Calzaghe?

[LacedUp]

A lot have scored it for Mayweather too. So.... and look who Castillo beat to win the title. Who did Kessler beat? I don't give a hell about ranking, who was the fighters he beat for the belt

Sure he beat it against a top fighter. In what fashion thought? An over the hill Johnston. But I won't go into that too much. Kessler beat a lot of top 10 fighters from 2005-2008 and he can only beat what's in his weightclass.

[BafanaBafana]

Stevie Johnston and Joel Casamayor are levels above any fighter that Kessler beat.

Well it's funny that you mentioned him since an old Casamayor beat both Castillo and Corrales including a TKO6 over Corrales. The best Corrales ever managed was a SD.

I rate both Kessler and Froch above Castillo and Corrales and I'm not a fan of either.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

This thread has proved one thing,,,

calzaghe fans are not as biased as floyd fans,,,

i have seen alot of calzaghe fans,, myself included, say floyd is ranked higher,,,
you would never see a floyd fan ever say anything negative about floyd....

They are still trying to defend his CW with canelo, and his fake retirements,,, lol

[A-Wolf]

Floyd by about 4,000,000 miles.

[InSaiyan]

Sure he beat it against a top fighter. In what fashion thought? An over the hill Johnston. But I won't go into that too much. Kessler beat a lot of top 10 fighters from 2005-2008 and he can only beat what's in his weightclass.

or Kessler could move up and look for bigger challenges?

Over the hill? Johnston was the big favorite going into the fight.

[InSaiyan]

Well it's funny that you mentioned him since an old Casamayor beat both Castillo and Corrales including a TKO6 over Corrales. The best Corrales ever managed was a SD.

I rate both Kessler and Froch above Castillo and Corrales and I'm not a fan of either.

Get off of boxrec

Corrales should really be 2-1 vs him and was going to stop Casamayor as Casamayor was running all over before the BS cut stoppage.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Well it's funny that you mentioned him since an old Casamayor beat both Castillo and Corrales including a TKO6 over Corrales. The best Corrales ever managed was a SD.

I rate both Kessler and Froch above Castillo and Corrales and I'm not a fan of either.

I think Casamoyer lost a SD to castillo,, im pretty sure,,, an casamoyer wasnt old when fighting those guys,,,
he was old when he fought marquez and bradley,, early 00s he was still prime

[InSaiyan]

I think Casamoyer lost a SD to castillo,, im pretty sure,,, an casamoyer wasnt old when fighting those guys,,,
he was old when he fought marquez and bradley,, early 00s he was still prime

Castillo beat Casamayor in their fight and rightly got the decision. I completely ignored that bull crap

[Homervanderjazz]

Calzaghe was good, greater than Floyd- no

[BafanaBafana]

I think Casamoyer lost a SD to castillo,, im pretty sure,,, an casamoyer wasnt old when fighting those guys,,,
he was old when he fought marquez and bradley,, early 00s he was still prime

Yeah, you're right about that, my bad. I've always felt those guys were ridiculously overrated though. Never saw them as being anything special, their best official wins are probably against each other and Casamayor.