Who ranks higher? Mayweathe or Calzaghe?

[slimshandy69]

**** thread..calzaghe schooled US best hall of famers...whos Mayweather that's not been cherry picked.

CALZAGHE a ATG, Mayweather just waits till hes bigger and younger than the guy then fights them.

Saul alvez fight only happened due to him losing 12 million

[LacedUp]

**** thread..calzaghe schooled US best hall of famers...whos Mayweather that's not been cherry picked.

CALZAGHE a ATG, Mayweather just waits till hes bigger and younger than the guy then fights them.

Saul alvez fight only happened due to him losing 12 million

You're about one post away from being put on ignore. If you don't like my threads, then piss off.

[low_Bo]

Martinez maybe in a few years, but PAC is younger than Floyd so that doesn't work.

I guess we could imagine a shuffling fortysomething Pac though. So if Floyd could magically wait till Pac was 40 without ageing himself, and follow that with 42 year old Martinez afterwards, that would be about right?
Sound like far worse cherrypicking than he currently does, correct me if I'm wrong. Don't see how that improves his record, it still makes him look a LOT worse to wait for them to age.

What makes Joe look better (?) makes Floyd look worse.??!

Manny is much older than jones and Hopkins were when fighting joe if you objectively look at his career and consider te mileage on the man. Manny had been in wars. How many wars has Floyd been in? Just because manny is younger than Floyd doesn't make him the fresher fighter.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

68 votes for Floyd.

14 trolls vote for Calzaghe.

Joe doesnt have half the resume or skill of Floyd Joy Mayweather.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

floyd ranks higher,,,

joe is great but floyd has just faced more top guys,,

joe has hopkins, kessler, lacy, and if your generous eubanks,,

floyd has genaro, corrales, castillo twice, oscar, hatton, and if your generous manfredy, cotto, shane
plus he has canelo soon....


floyd has to rank higher,,,

[InSaiyan]

mayweather. too bad joe didn't move up sooner he could've gotten better versions of jones, and fought johnson, harding, griffen, michaelczweski, tarver etc.

[low_Bo]

floyd ranks higher,,,

joe is great but floyd has just faced more top guys,,

joe has hopkins, kessler, lacy, and if your generous eubanks,,

floyd has genaro, corrales, castillo twice, oscar, hatton, and if your generous manfredy, cotto, shane
plus he has canelo soon....


floyd has to rank higher,,,

Joe has 2 atg wins. Mayweather 0.

[LacedUp]

Joe has 2 atg wins. Mayweather 0.

If you count Jones Jr as an ATG win, then you also have to count Oscar.

[InSaiyan]

If you count Jones Jr as an ATG win, then you also have to count Oscar.

mayweather beat oscar, mosley and marquez...they are atgs are they not?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Roy Jones is an ATG win to Calzaghe fans? They are just as dellusional as Joe was back when he was so happy he was fighting a "legend".