Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[tangalog2200]

Oh god you guys are so ******ed. Pacquaios last 3 opponents have all been on the P4P list, his ****ing loss to Bradley OBVIOUSLY isn't taken seriously in rankings because it was a blatant robbery, so besides that his legit loss came to Marquez, a fellow HIGHLY ranked P4P fighter. Losing to a P4P fighter doesn't make you get thrown off the list, especially when you are winning the fight up until the loss.

Use your damn brains and common sense, hes lost once recently, losing once doesn't throw you off the list unless its vs a BUM fighter who had no chance in the first place. Is Marquez a bum fighter? Didn't think so.

You expect Bradley and how **** he performed vs Pacquaio & Ruslan who pretty much demolished him to be on the P4P rankings? Rofl, cool story.

this makes sense.........

there appears some get a myopic view of p4p listings................

ali is the greatest....

even after so so loses many still considered him the greatest....

what a boxer had accomplished etched in the memories of boxing fans could not be just erased by having some loses....

it is how and who he fought that people appreciate...

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Um, what? Sorry, but no.

What do you mean no??

He was beating jmm till a perfect counter from jmm and he dominated bradley...

Yes he got beat by JMM but i dont penalize guys for losing to another p4p guy.

Just like how i dont penalize jmm for losing to mayweather..

But when they get beat down by non-p4p guys like serg was vs murray it does hurt their ranking

I think manny getting ko'd drops him from top 5 to bottom part of top 10

[LoadedWraps]

What do you mean no??

He was beating jmm till a perfect counter from jmm and he dominated bradley...

Yes he got beat by JMM but i dont penalize guys for losing to another p4p guy.

Just like how i dont penalize jmm for losing to mayweather..

But when they get beat down by non-p4p guys like serg was vs murray it does hurt their ranking

I think manny getting ko'd drops him from top 5 to bottom part of top 10

He was maybe slightly ahead of JMM on the scorecards but unless that was your first Marquez/Manny fight you should know it was going to be close at worst. Also Bradley won that fight whether you like it or not. You don't penalize one p4p losing to another? Ridiculous.
Manny drops out of the top ten easily. Losing 2 out of 3? Unbecoming of a top ten p4p.

[Weebler I]

He was maybe slightly ahead of JMM on the scorecards but unless that was your first Marquez/Manny fight you should know it was going to be close at worst. Also Bradley won that fight whether you like it or not. You don't penalize one p4p losing to another? Ridiculous.
Manny drops out of the top ten easily. Losing 2 out of 3? Unbecoming of a top ten p4p.

Not even Tim Bradley believes he won that fight.

[El Angel]

And Ward at #1? I'm liking this list Cliff

[dan_cov]

Solid list in my book, nice to see Roman Gonzalez in there.

[Yaconcha]

andre ward has 2 top names at the weight on his record.
floyd mayweather has over twenty.
thick ****s.

[Ichee]

By a roided opponent who was losing the fight. Fcuk that, Pacquiao was beating Marquez and he beat Bradley too, he deserves to retain a spot in the top 10.

He does not deserve to retain a spot after losing like that! Please be considerate here, what great fighter in history have been devastatingly knocked out and was still showcased on the P4P list? I am a Pacquiao fan I want him to be number 1 but he is just not the same anymore.. man just let it go, you are giving Pacquiao fans a bad name by being illogical on this matter.

[Weebler I]

He does not deserve to retain a spot after losing like that! Please be considerate here, what great fighter in history have been devastatingly knocked out and was still showcased on the P4P list? I am a Pacquiao fan I want him to be number 1 but he is just not the same anymore.. man just let it go, you are giving Pacquiao fans a bad name by being illogical on this matter.

He was winning? you make it sound like he was getting outclassed before being knocked out. Anyone can get caught with a shot and we're not talking some scrub who stopped him, we're talking about an atg fighter in Marquez.

Pacquiao's ranking deserves to take a hit, but not the whole way off the list.

[HeroBando]

He does not deserve to retain a spot after losing like that! Please be considerate here, what great fighter in history have been devastatingly knocked out and was still showcased on the P4P list? I am a Pacquiao fan I want him to be number 1 but he is just not the same anymore.. man just let it go, you are giving Pacquiao fans a bad name by being illogical on this matter.

Can;t be that illogical if he is still in every decent p4p list. You run some blog called the Logic of Boxing?