Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

[LoadedWraps]

Duran is higher, and I really wish people would stop bringing up Floyd and Manny in ATG lists until they retire.

[king4oranges]

Floyd "money" Mayweather. he has a ****ty personality but he one of the best ever.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

This is a dumb poll but a good way for the mods to decide who should get banned and who shouldn't.

[radioraheem]

LOL @ Floyd never fought anyone bigger than him. The ****** and the Ginger were bigger. Corrales and Castillo were bigger. Baldomir was bigger even though he was slow as a snail.

That's even more laughable than picking Floyd over Duran all time

Join date: March 2014.

What was your previous username?

Sorry, but he is correct. Me personally, I think it's silly to make the comparisons because of the difference in eras and time.

But you cannot say that Floyd didn't fight bigger fighters. For most of his career, he's fought bigger guys. Many of the guys he's fought have outweighed him by as much as 10+ lbs. And that's fact, not fiction.

[SweetPbfAli]

Sorry, but he is correct. Me personally, I think it's silly to make the comparisons because of the difference in eras and time.

But you cannot say that Floyd didn't fight bigger fighters. For most of his career, he's fought bigger guys. Many of the guys he's fought have outweighed him by as much as 10+ lbs. And that's fact, not fiction.

Holy ****! Ortiz was 164 on fight night? Wtf? lol

[sugarsmosley]

floyd weighed in at 160 vs the big show in wrestlemania....

[sugarsmosley]

duran is a top 10 fighter ever..... why are people insulted. thats like ali being insulted that sugar ray robinson is ahead of him.... when you get to the very tippy top of the sports history that shows enough

[Holywarrior]

duran is a top 10 fighter ever..... why are people insulted. thats like ali being insulted that sugar ray robinson is ahead of him.... when you get to the very tippy top of the sports history that shows enough

Yup, and even then there is a huge gap between the top 5 and 6-10 fighters ever.

Imagine, Charles, Armstrong, Robinson, etc. vs Ali, Duran, Moore

No shame in this of course, but there is quite a gap between the sections.

[slimshandy69]

Easily Duran.

Floyd's on his health first route and won't fight anyone worth a damn. The ones that are actual threats, he just chooses to duck them.

great post. Duran it is...

[sugarsmosley]

Yup, and even then there is a huge gap between the top 5 and 6-10 fighters ever.

Imagine, Charles, Armstrong, Robinson, etc. vs Ali, Duran, Moore

No shame in this of course, but there is quite a gap between the sections.

what do you mean. all those fighters you just named are all among the very greatest ever... all those guys u named are in that level i said, the very top of the sports history. mythical status but u know what im saying

i dont think a huge gap can exist between fighters that great. how could u say something like ali is far greater then say henry armstrong... u just dont say those kinda things