Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

[Szef]

Floyd tested his limits.

Floyd asked his limits to rehydrate 2 pounds.

Only thing he doesnt have over Duran resume and thats because that calibre of fighter Duran had to pick from Floyd didnt.

Don't even make me go there.

[KingTito]

Duran. I can't take anyone seriously if they try to make a case for Floyd.

[Kuyukut]

the truth is, floyd the fraud holds the record of the weakest resume of any fighter ever to hold the p4p list.

i don't think it will ever be broken.

[Shambrolic]

I may be in a minorty and i really love Duran but Mayweather have accomplished a lot more. Duran may have a lot of names on his win record but there are not many substantive fighters on his list he beat besides Leonard and Barkley. This two arguably have done less than Mayweather as well by this point. Mayweather have almost 20 champions on his resume with a multitude if styles. Duran head to head with Mayweather will not beat him based off how Leonard showcased movement against him. However we are basing this on resume and once September ended with Floyd victorious I have to say him right now.

[Oasis_Lad]

I may be in a minorty and i really love Duran but Mayweather have accomplished a lot more. Duran may have a lot of names on his win record but there are not many substantive fighters on his list he beat besides Leonard and Barkley. This two arguably have done less than Mayweather as well by this point. Mayweather have almost 20 champions on his resume with a multitude if styles. Duran head to head with Mayweather will not beat him based off how Leonard showcased movement against him. However we are basing this on resume and once September ended with Floyd victorious I have to say him right now.

[Kuyukut]

I may be in a minorty and i really love Duran but Mayweather have accomplished a lot more. Duran may have a lot of names on his win record but there are not many substantive fighters on his list he beat besides Leonard and Barkley. This two arguably have done less than Mayweather as well by this point. Mayweather have almost 20 champions on his resume with a multitude if styles. Duran head to head with Mayweather will not beat him based off how Leonard showcased movement against him. However we are basing this on resume and once September ended with Floyd victorious I have to say him right now.

funniest post ever this year! green k given.

[Shambrolic]

funniest post ever this year! green k given.

Are you freedom2014 who instead given me bad rep? I mean this is my opinion we can all be civil here and discuss. What's the point of a topic and poll if you are going to resort to underhand tactics and be upset at someone opinion that is not yours?

This is why I just read replies most of the time.. You guys do not answer or post off your own boxing knowledge(if you have any) but off word of mouth and bias bandwagons.

[Ham Porter]

Will Floyd, who is taller with a longer reach than Duran, ever move up to middleweight and win a title?

Duran didn't demand a catch weight when he fought Barkley.

He asked for one for the third Leonard fight, though.

[BUNGALOWS]

25 people have gone full ******.

[M Bison]

Not even close for me, Duran takes it by a landslide.