Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[HeroBando]

It should be #1 Floyd ( until he retires or gets beat) #2 Ward better boxer and resume than Pac and Martinez. #3 Martinez Better boxer and better recent resume than Pac. Then I don't care how the rest goes.

You mean, better recent resume vs Pac for Ward? And some other reason for Martinez? Cause none of his last 4 opponents were top 50 p4p.

[J Dubb II 330]

You mean, better recent resume vs Pac for Ward? And some other reason for Martinez? Cause none of his last 4 opponents were top 50 p4p.

Yes but they were young undefeated prime contenders . Aside from.Macklin 3 losses and Williams and Pavlik each had one loss. Versus Pac who just recently finally fought a prime boxer and got beat .

[HeroBando]

Yes but they were young undefeated prime contenders . Aside from.Macklin 3 losses and Williams and Pavlik each had one loss. Versus Pac who just recently finally fought a prime boxer and got beat .

LMAO at prime Barker. Dz was not prime, he'd only fought an Aussie clubfighter in 2 years. Chavez was considered a joke by almost everyone before beating beastly Lee, you saw him need generous judging against featherfisted bum Zbik.

I guess you're one of the 3% that had p4per Bradley beating Pac:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

[J Dubb II 330]

What's your definition of prime then lol. Chavez is a very good boxer. He got brought up slow nut that doesn't take away from his skill. Dzinziruk was the 154 champ.

Yup me and the judges saw the fight right.

Is it any wonder why Pac chose Marquez

[DeadLikeMe]

I remember BHop fell like 7 spots one year for dominating two guys who were considered average opponents. P4P rankings need to go back to how they used to be. Ten years ago Manny wouldn't even be ranked from his laughable opponents and mediocre showings against weak opposition, Floyd would probably be like 8th from beating Ortiz and Cotto.

P4P rankings have become a complete joke over the last 10 years.

[bballchump11]

holy **** that list is bad. Only Ellie Seckbach's list is worse than this

[HeroBando]

What's your definition of prime then lol. Chavez is a very good boxer. He got brought up slow nut that doesn't take away from his skill. Dzinziruk was the 154 champ.

Yup me and the judges saw the fight right.

Is it any wonder why Pac chose Marquez

No comment needed on that.

I take it you were with the judges on Abril Rios, PWill Lara, Casa JASC, Pea Ramirez/Chavez...

You'd be surprised, a lot more people had JMM beating Pac last time around, compared to Bradley. By a factor of 10-20 or so. In fact in 3 tries, he's been way more competitive than Tim, each time. Only according to an overwhelming majority

[Larry the boss]

how is floyd ranked under manny??he just won 2 titles and manny just had to terrible fights??how is this even possible?

[HeroBando]

how is floyd ranked under manny??he just won 2 titles and manny just had to terrible fights??how is this even possible?

Both BS editors had him beating JMM. And everyone had him beating Bradley, mostly wide/dominant. So according to BS, that's 2 p4p wins in 12 months. How many other p4pers have even fought 2 Ring/consensus p4pers in 1 year recently?

[Evol]

how is floyd ranked under manny??he just won 2 titles and manny just had to terrible fights??how is this even possible?

Cuz PAC > Floyd lol haha..