Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[J Dubb II 330]

No comment needed on that.

I take it you were with the judges on Abril Rios, PWill Lara, Casa JASC, Pea Ramirez/Chavez...

You'd be surprised, a lot more people had JMM beating Pac last time around, compared to Bradley. By a factor of 10-20 or so. In fact in 3 tries, he's been way more competitive than Tim, each time. Only according to an overwhelming majority

No no I wasn't.

Like I said its a wonder why he chose Marquez instead of Bradley.

And it doesn't surprise me people think Marquez beat Pac, I'm one of them.

Pac looked bad against Bradley missing wildly, its his celebrity status and diehard fans that believe he won. How could a "nobody" beat the Great Pac. Lamply **** riding calling out punches that were clearly missing. And at the same time not given Bradley credit for the work he was doing.

E. steward slipped up when he said Pac since the 3rd round can only land 1-2 clean punches a round , yet he believed that was good enough to win rounds.

[HeroBando]

No no I wasn't.

Like I said its a wonder why he chose Marquez instead of Bradley.

And it doesn't surprise me people think Marquez beat Pac, I'm one of them.

Pac looked bad against Bradley missing wildly, its his celebrity status and diehard fans that believe he won. How could a "nobody" beat the Great Pac. Lamply **** riding calling out punches that were clearly missing. And at the same time not given Bradley credit for the work he was doing.

E. steward slipped up when he said Pac since the 3rd round can only land 1-2 clean punches a round , yet he believed that was good enough to win rounds.

I just gave you a link with the press row scores, it was like 95% for Pac, mostly wide. The average score was something like 117-111. Are you saying these guys streamed HBO on their cellphones?

[J Dubb II 330]

I just gave you a link with the press row scores, it was like 95% for Pac, mostly wide. The average score was something like 117-111. Are you saying these guys streamed HBO on their cellphones?

Lol um no. I.was just making a statement about Lamply

Those guys don't matter. Brian Kenny scored it for Bradley. So I guess he does not know what he is talking about.

It don't matter who says what. The point is the judges scored it for.Bradley. he won and has the belt and nothing will ever change it

[HeroBando]

Lol um no. I.was just making a statement about Lamply

Those guys don't matter. Brian Kenny scored it for Bradley. So I guess he does not know what he is talking about.

It don't matter who says what. The point is the judges scored it for.Bradley. he won and has the belt and nothing will ever change it

You don't believe there is such a thing as a robbery in boxing? I guess you agree with all of these outcomes, the judges know best:

Abril Rios, PWill Lara, Casa JASC, Pea Ramirez/Chavez, Campillo Cloud/Shumenov, Lewis Holyfield 1...

Besides, this one has pretty much gone into the books as a robbery, see this disclaimer on boxrec LMAO:

"After a thorough review by five veteran judges commissioned by the WBO, Pacquiao was declared the unanimous decision winner by the panel, but Bradley is nevertheless still the WBO's welterweight champion."

[Larry the boss]

Both BS editors had him beating JMM. And everyone had him beating Bradley, mostly wide/dominant. So according to BS, that's 2 p4p wins in 12 months. How many other p4pers have even fought 2 Ring/consensus p4pers in 1 year recently?

but you can't just make up wins man and say forget the official scores he won and then ignore the previous fight where alot of people think he lost..how is that not being biased?

[Larry the boss]

You don't believe there is such a thing as a robbery in boxing? I guess you agree with all of these outcomes, the judges know best:

Abril Rios, PWill Lara, Casa JASC, Pea Ramirez/Chavez, Campillo Cloud/Shumenov, Lewis Holyfield 1...

Besides, this one has pretty much gone into the books as a robbery, see this disclaimer on boxrec LMAO:

"After a thorough review by five veteran judges commissioned by the WBO, Pacquiao was declared the unanimous decision winner by the panel, but Bradley is nevertheless still the WBO's welterweight champion."

so why didnt the WBO keep Mann as champion?

[HeroBando]

so why didnt the WBO keep Mann as champion?

Because they can't change the result, it's the commission's job

[HeroBando]

but you can't just make up wins man and say forget the official scores he won and then ignore the previous fight where alot of people think he lost..how is that not being biased?

Here's those links again:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma..._(3rd_meeting)
http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

Notice that Pac Bradley was a landslide according to the press row. 95%+ for Pac, with avg score like 117-111.

Notice JMM was very close according to the press guys. Cliff and Jake from BS both had it for Pac, hence their p4p ratings.

[Larry the boss]

Because they can't change the result, it's the commission's job

no a sanctioning body can decide to keep the other person as champion

[Larry the boss]

Here's those links again:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma..._(3rd_meeting)
http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

Notice that Pac Bradley was a landslide according to the press row. 95%+ for Pac, with avg score like 117-111.

Notice JMM was very close according to the press guys. Cliff and Jake from BS both had it for Pac, hence their p4p ratings.

but after the manny-jmm fight manny got hit in the head with a cup cause they were throwing stuff in the ring..just saying man that is some biased ****..and if you wanna talk p4p..why wasnt floyd #1 when he dominated jmm and shane back to back??they were p4p #2 and #3...