Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[Larry the boss]

so why do u have martinez number 3? have you seen his last 3 fights? macklin barker and chavez? lol

who has bradley beat? and dont say pacquiao.

Martinez has defended his lineal title 5 times

and Bradley damn near cleaned out 140 and moved up to beat Manny

[-PANDA-]

marquez should not be rated so high...his resume these past two years hasnt been that great. even though he deserved to win the last pac fight, guys like fedchenko, ramos and even katsidis at this point dont validate him being top 5 p4p. also he's barely been kept busier than floyd or pac, against lesser opposition

[FeFist]

I saw Ward at no. 1 and it made me smile, I saw Pacquiao at no. 2 and instantly the whole list lost its credibility. What does a fighter have to do nowadays to move down the list. He has an official loss, that's discounted because many feel he won. He has an unofficial loss and that's discounted because it is not official.

Just pure double standards.

[revs1227]

Pefect list aside from Cotto I dnt think he's top ten material the trout fight will prove this , PAC. Is def number two and I guess Mayweathers 3 I'd pik Martinez I don't see how cheapshotting Ortiz who got beatemore decisive by josito Lopez n Ud a shot Cotto keep u in p4p lisr lol
Pac beat the hell outta a much better fighter in tim Bradley who I'd have in cottos spot

[HeroBando]

I saw Ward at no. 1 and it made me smile, I saw Pacquiao at no. 2 and instantly the whole list lost its credibility. What does a fighter have to do nowadays to move down the list. He has an official loss, that's discounted because many feel he won. He has an unofficial loss and that's discounted because it is not official.

Just pure double standards.

Not at all, Cliff scored Pac JMM 3 for Pac, and he's not the only one

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma..._(3rd_meeting)

Compare Pac Bradley, which was a whitewash on press row scorecards:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

[revs1227]

Exactly. It's not the brothers fault. They are the single most dominant force in boxing. They absolutely dominate heavyweight. No other champion or pfp fighter are that dominant in any weight class.

Yes this ... Dominance

[HOLLYW00]

wow that post had a lot of depth to it, care to explain or you just talking out your dumb ass like you usually do?

Please explain why you have MARQUEZ AND MARTINEZ infront of WARD.. Ain't no answer you can come up with that can back up your ******ed list.

[Canelo Phresh]

Sergio should be ahead of Floyd and Manny.

[Bushbaby]

i appreciate its not the brothers fault. they are the most dominant because they fight the weakest opposition. no other weight class is as weak so maybe thats why!

i mean did anybody sit through wlad vs mormeck? i mean jeeeeeesus!

They also fight in the worst weight class in boxing. Its not their fault sure but its still a reality.

I do agree that heavyweight is rather weak. But the fact remains that the 2 headed Klitchko monster are the dominant force there. You line em up, they destroy them.

147
154
160

The other top pfp fighters reside there & the reality is that Floyd, Martinez, nor Pacman have cleaned out any of those divisions. So why should I give these guys credit but not the brothers when at least the brothers have cleaned out heavyweight & return now & then to lift any specks of dirt??

I give them all credit, but I won't disrespect the brothers & big up the others when the brothers are the 1 that rule there division with an iron fist.

[HOLLYW00]

I saw Ward at no. 1 and it made me smile, I saw Pacquiao at no. 2 and instantly the whole list lost its credibility. What does a fighter have to do nowadays to move down the list. He has an official loss, that's discounted because many feel he won. He has an unofficial loss and that's discounted because it is not official.

Just pure double standards.

My thoughts exactly.. Pacquiao can't be that high after he lost to Bradley.. A loss is a loss and shouldn't be rated different because he should've won. He took the L