Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[Larry the boss]

Pac Cotto happened after FMJ JMM. Right before that you had the spectacular KO of Hatton. Please recall the timeline before complaining about this.

no you said after floyd returned he had a "spectacular run"but he did not and floyds win since his return are alot better than mannys

[HeroBando]

he remained champ months before the result was overturned..no matter if it was over turned of not Hopkins was going to remain the champion

abril -rios...abril lost but kept his interim title

Again totally different circumstances. Abril Rios was not even contested for Abril's interim belt, it was for Rios's full belt that he gave up at the weighin. Notice they didn't award Abril the regular belt despite the robbery. What are you trying to prove with this anyway?

[HeroBando]

no you said after floyd returned he had a "spectacular run"but he did not and floyds win since his return are alot better than mannys

You said that JMM + Mosley should have been enough to put FMJ back at #1. I'm telling you that Pac was on a great streak at the time. You responded by listing a bunch of Pac fights that happened after FMJ Mosley, sometimes years later. Pac Cotto was only 6 months before FMJ Mosley, and Pac Hatton 1 year earlier. That makes them highly relevant ranking wise.