Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[THE REED]

Pretty good list. Can't have Mayweather 1-2 because of his inactivity. If he fought more he would be there. I would probably put Wlad higher...

He just fought five months ago, what are you talking about.

[Daddy T]

I liked BoxingScene's reasoning for Manny Pacquiao.

"We don't like the decision, so we're going to ignore it"

and they were right to do so, anybody with eyes could see that he won. Good list imo.

[djeffectz]

Pac should be number 1
Ward is fine at 2
May is sitting pretty at 3
Martinez at 4 is perfect


Thats the current p4p

[Grimgash]

Pac should be number 1
Ward is fine at 2
May is sitting pretty at 3
Martinez at 4 is perfect


Thats the current p4p

......What reasoning do you have for this list? Ward May and Martinez all have been better recently than pac... The only downside to Ward is him not moving divisions but he's young. It may be too early to crown him but I'm okay with it at the same time. JMM really shouldn't be that high either yeah he has a solid skill set if you want to base it off that but...in that case anyone who says that should have Floyd #1 his skill set >>>> JMM. Just trying to be reasonable here. The list is tough to say because resume wise recently You'd have Ward first but skill set wise you wouldn't.

[NearHypnos]

Pac can lose fights and still not drop? Lol what.

[beast702]

1. Manny
2. Floyd
3. Martinez
4. Ward
5. Donaire
6.Marquez
7. Vitali
8. Wladimir
9. Froch
10. Cotto

Yes I think Manny beats Floyd. As of for Martinez and Ward they can be flipflopped as they both had big impressive wins.

[HeroBando]

Pac can lose fights and still not drop? Lol what.

Both Cliff and Jake had him beating JMM 3, and everybody had him beating Bradley

[Sinisterevo]

I got Mayweather #1, Ward #2, Martinez #3, Pacquiao #4, Donaire #5

[J Dubb II 330]

It should be #1 Floyd ( until he retires or gets beat) #2 Ward better boxer and resume than Pac and Martinez. #3 Martinez Better boxer and better recent resume than Pac. Then I don't care how the rest goes.

[Sugar Q]

The best way to look at P4P is "WHO HAS BEATEN MORE FIGHTERS WHILE THEY WERE RANKED P4P TOP 10" I rest my case.

1) Mayweather
2) Ward
3) The Klitchsko Bros
4) Martinez
5) Bradley/JMM/Pac