Better resume Jmm or Cotto

[ELHURACAN58]

Why would that make his resume better?

Cause it shows he cant be beaten easily.

[AntDawg]

Who has the better resume and who should get inducted in the hall of fame first?

Jmm-
1-Barerra
2-Casamyor
3-Diaz
4-Juarez
5-Katsidas

Cotto

1-Mosley
2-Margo
3-Quintana
4-Judah
5-Mallinaggi

Man looking at Marquez opponents I'll go with Cotto lol. Katsidas was never that good...Juaraez never even won a belt...Casamyor was shot to **** and Diaz was never that good to me either.

[AntDawg]

Oh and no Clottey on Cotto's list?

[4Corners]

Marquez easily. You should also add Norwood, Pacquiao, and John pretty much as well. He should have at the very least one win over Pacquiao, and he beat Norwood and John.

You left Salido, Gainer, and Polo off Marquez' list too. Those are good wins.

[Chups]

Marquez, and it's not even close.

Also you forgot Pacquiao's name from his list of wins.

I lol'ed.

[Twako]

it's very tempting to quickly say jmm has the better resume. but really, his best performances were officially 2 losses and a draw with pac. let's go by official records shall we? because if not, oscar would suddenly shoot up inside the ATG list with his 'supposed wins' against mosley and trinidad!

[WARQUEZ]

it's very tempting to quickly say jmm has the better resume. but really, his best performances were officially 2 losses and a draw with pac. let's go by official records shall we? because if not, oscar would suddenly shoot up inside the ATG list with his 'supposed wins' against mosley and trinidad!

Nah, those loses to Whitaker, Sturm, and you can even make a case for Quartey would be too much.

[Twako]

Nah, those loses to Whitaker, Sturm, and you can even make a case for Quartey would be too much.

yeah basically what i'm saying. we're just flipping supposed wins and losses here. so best to base it on official records right?

[WARQUEZ]

yeah basically what i'm saying. we're just flipping supposed wins and losses here. so best to base it on official records right?

Heck no. I refuse to accept decisions from crooked judges. Just my opinion though, it doesn't matter anyway because Marquez still has the better resume without the Pac wins.

[Twako]

Heck no. I refuse to accept decisions from crooked judges. Just my opinion though, it doesn't matter anyway because Marquez still has the better resume without the Pac wins.

i dont disagree with jmm having the better one, but based on official stats, imo it's not miles away from cotto as some posters here are quick to say.