Boxing fan ask Breadman "Would Pac beat Hearns, Leonard, Duran & Trinidad?"

[jrosales13]

"Pacquiao never wins fantasy fights."

Translation: I'm too ****** to understand style match ups, fighter's strengths/weaknesses, and don't know what skill is even if it was Eva Mendes trying to get into my pants. Let alone explain how Pacquiao could win a fight.

Says the guy that thinks Jorge Linares would beat Pac at 126/130

[F l i c k e r]

Says the guy that thinks Jorge Linares would beat Pac at 126/130

Dude, apparently you don't have any reading comprehension. Or do you just look at sentences and pick out certain words to construct your own sentence to make believe that was said?


As I recall saying, "FREDDIE ROACH SAID, with more experience Jorge Linares could probably beat Pacquiao."

[sdcluser]

Do You Agree with Bread's response?

Hey Bread, Check this out I'm arguing with this dude. I hate getting into these type of debates on who beats who but here it goes !!

1. Pac vs Hearns at 147lbs?

2. Pac vs Leonard at 147lbs?

3. Pac vs Duran at 135lbs?

4. Prime Pac vs. Prime Trinidad at 147lbs?

Greatly appreciated I know it's all opinion


Bread’s Response: The Pac fans may hate me for this but I think he loses ALL of these fights. He probably gets stopped too. He has his best chance against Trinidad, but I would go the much bigger Trinidad in a brutal war.

Pac has a shot againt Trinidad. But most likely he would lose to Leonard, Hearn at 147 and lost against Duran at 135. I don't think Mayweather would win against Hearn in 12 rds.

[KickAzz]

Translation: I'm too ****** to understand style match ups, fighter's strengths/weaknesses, and don't know what skill is even if it was Eva Mendes trying to get into my pants. Let alone explain how Pacquiao could win a fight.

Translation: I'm a little girl living in a fantasy world

[4Corners]

Leonard would UD Pac at 147, most likely 117-111/118-111/118-110. Leonard was one of the greatest, Mayweather and Pac are as well...but Sugar Ray Leonard was just a level above those guys. If May beats Pac or vice-versa, there ATG status greatly increases in my opinion.

I would bet on Hearns to beat Pac at 147 as well, but it may be closer than some think. I can see Pac hitting Hearns with some of those huge combo's, but Hearns would get off big time on Pac as well, simply because Manny really has no defense. I don't know if he would stop Pac, as it seems like Manny has a pretty good chin. He may stop Pac late in maybe the 10th or 11th, or win a sort of close UD. The scorecards would be around 116-112, 117-112, 116-111.

Duran would beat Pac at 135. The only time we saw Pac at 135 was against a past prime-still good Diaz in 08'. Duran may have been the best Lightweight ever. It would be a war, but I would predict either a close UD win for Duran, or he would stop him in the mid-to-late rounds (8 or 9). Most people out-boxed Duran to beat him, which is why Pac wouldn't. If Pac were able to find a way to beat Duran, I could see it being a great trilogy, in which Duran wins 2 of 3.

I may actually pick Pacquiao to beat Trinidad at 147. Felix was an ATG, definitely solidified it with his win over a prime De La Hoya. Pac has as much hand speed as Trinidad though, and great power at WW as we've seen. I would say the fights would be close decisions (Split Decisions and Majority Decisions), with them splitting the first 2. The 3rd fight would be a 50/50. I can't really give a winner.

[IMDAZED]

Pac has a shot againt Trinidad. But most likely he would lose to Leonard, Hearn at 147 and lost against Duran at 135. I don't think Mayweather would win against Hearn in 12 rds.

Pac doesn't have a shot against Tito. At all.

[sdcluser]

Pac doesn't have a shot against Tito. At all.

What is your reason that he doesn't have a shot?

[F l i c k e r]

Translation: I'm a little girl living in a fantasy world

Your simply too ****** to make an argument for pacquiao. Easy to nut hug but not so easy to evaluate skills and breakdown a fight huh? Stick to nuthugging and dissing *****s.

[KickAzz]

Your simply too ****** to make an argument for pacquiao. Easy to nut hug but not so easy to evaluate skills and breakdown a fight huh? Stick to nuthugging and dissing *****s.

hey little girl, what do you want for your birthday? A new training bra or some tampons?

[jrosales13]

Dude, apparently you don't have any reading comprehension. Or do you just look at sentences and pick out certain words to construct your own sentence to make believe that was said?


As I recall saying, "FREDDIE ROACH SAID, with more experience Jorge Linares could probably beat Pacquiao."

The one who doesn't have reading comprehension is you... Show me where I did in what you accuse me off here.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=361472

lol, hell yeah. I think Linares would beat Pacquiao at 126 too. If you look at that video, Jorge's right hand is like a bullet from a 50 cal rifle. Straight down the pipe on a southpaw is bad news.

Did you even watch the video? Have you even seen Jorge fight?

Jorge's mix of power, quickness, footwork, speed, leverage would have dominated Pac at featherweight. Not to mention Pac's chin wasn't what I would call the best at 126.

lol, hell yeah. I think Linares would beat Pacquiao at 126 too. If you look at that video, Jorge's right hand is like a bullet from a 50 cal rifle. Straight down the pipe on a southpaw is bad news.

Thats sarcasm. lol

At 126 i think he can beat Pacquiao. Pacquiao wasn't the juggernaught he is today back at 126. At 126 he was getting out-boxed by shot fighters, and tasted the canvas multiple times against old dudes.

Now how would Pacquiao fair at 126 against a young dude with a high-end skill set?

Thats why I said "i'm not saying Linares is Marquez."

Pacquiao at featherweight vs high-end skill. He doesn't look too good. Then you add that he faught old guys, albeit super feather, and got boxed good (even though he came out victor). You can't help but wonder, what if he faught high-end skill in a younger body.

I think Linares would whoop him. Pacquiao at lighweight and up, I wouldn't even make an argument for Pacquiao's opponent.

Just because he was unknown doesn't mean he sucks. The dude was Undefeated when he faught Linares. And since then he only lost to 1 guy and that is Uchiyama who is also undefeated; number 1 in japan, and number 4 in the world.



Why are you on Boxing Scene. This aint a basketball forum nor is it the lounge.


In defense of Jorge. Pacquiao and Jorge have both faught Oscar Larios. In the same year too. Pacquiao had a UD against Oscar Larios, going all 12. Linares beat the **** out of him in 10. A year later.

Jorge would beat Pacquiao. Sorry guys. I like Pac too but the skills pay bills.

"Whoop him"

Where am I taking your words out of context? Is this not what you said? You think Linares beats Pac at 126.