Lets settle this once and for all! Who really won Ortiz or Peterson?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rome-By-Ko
    The winner Is
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Mar 2009
    • 20157
    • 323
    • 332
    • 29,833

    #51
    Originally posted by ablindwatchmakr
    I'm not saying Ortiz is a technical phenom or anything, I'm just saying he could have outboxed and knocked out MAIDANA, a guy who probably can't spell boxing. Ortiz was winning the fight by a wide margin when he lost. The only round he lost was when he quit between rounds. That is it. So all you have against Ortiz is Maidana and Peterson. Two very close fights, one of which was being dominated by Ortiz until the end...C'mon dude.
    Damn Ortiz won every rd except the rd in which the fight ended..****,my card was closer then that..I know my cards were closer..Ortiz is a good fighter,but he has done nothing to make me think he is a better(or far better as ya put it)fighter then Peterson..

    Comment

    • Evil Abed
      The Darkest Timeline...
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Nov 2009
      • 21964
      • 979
      • 1,320
      • 30,552

      #52
      Originally posted by Shadows
      I did not.

      I haven't watched it since a few days after the fight aired live. I scored it then.
      I'm fairly sure that 95-93 is impossible without an even round.

      You must mean 96-94 Ortiz.

      Comment

      • Rome-By-Ko
        The winner Is
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Mar 2009
        • 20157
        • 323
        • 332
        • 29,833

        #53
        Originally posted by ThePhantom5


        Check out the 4th round again.
        Now check I did not look back at my scorecard,I just watch that rd again..I thought it was still close..Peterson landed some effective shots,but he did not control it..Felt a bit even if I could be honest but I could see Ortiz maybe taking it based on his activity..I don't remember what I scored the 4th on my cards but watching it just now with the sound down as well..I say it felt even but can't be mad if someone gave it to Ortiz based on activity..

        Comment

        • Shadows
          All-Time Great
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Jul 2009
          • 8293
          • 192
          • 250
          • 15,434

          #54
          Originally posted by ThePhantom5
          I'm fairly sure that 95-93 is impossible without an even round.

          You must mean 96-94 Ortiz.
          I had it even in terms of rounds, 5-5.

          Then take off the two points for the KDs.

          Unless my math is worse than I thought....

          Comment

          • Rome-By-Ko
            The winner Is
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Mar 2009
            • 20157
            • 323
            • 332
            • 29,833

            #55
            Originally posted by ThePhantom5


            Check out the 4th round again.
            Just looked back at my card and it's crazy that's how I felt Ortiz was busy but Peterson was a bit more effective..These two needs to fight again,I think I would go to it..

            Comment

            • Evil Abed
              The Darkest Timeline...
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Nov 2009
              • 21964
              • 979
              • 1,320
              • 30,552

              #56
              Originally posted by Rome-By-Ko
              Now check I did not look back at my scorecard,I just watch that rd again..I thought it was still close..Peterson landed some effective shots,but he did not control it..Felt a bit even if I could be honest but I could see Ortiz maybe taking it based on his activity..I don't remember what I scored the 4th on my cards but watching it just now with the sound down as well..I say it felt even but can't be mad if someone gave it to Ortiz based on activity..
              Fair enough.

              Comment

              • Evil Abed
                The Darkest Timeline...
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Nov 2009
                • 21964
                • 979
                • 1,320
                • 30,552

                #57
                Originally posted by Rome-By-Ko
                Just looked back at my card and it's crazy that's how I felt Ortiz was busy but Peterson was a bit more effective..These two needs to fight again,I think I would go to it..
                What really shocked me was that in the 8th round I believe, Lamont hurt Ortiz.

                Comment

                • Kagami Taiga
                  Generation of Miracles
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 19078
                  • 703
                  • 228
                  • 40,183

                  #58
                  im a fan of both fighters, a bigger ortiz fan than i am a peterson fan. with that said i was fine with the draw. ortiz might have really won but en then he didnt deserve it. and plus i think it served as a wakeup call for ortiz. great fight tho.

                  Comment

                  • Rome-By-Ko
                    The winner Is
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Mar 2009
                    • 20157
                    • 323
                    • 332
                    • 29,833

                    #59
                    Originally posted by ThePhantom5
                    What really shocked me was that in the 8th round I believe, Lamont hurt Ortiz.
                    I know I really believe Peterson's power is underrated..He hurt Bradley to the body when they fought...

                    The bad thing about Peterson is it seems he has to be hit or hurt to make him notice hey I'm in a fight..Then he fights up to the level of the fighter he is fighting..If he could start how he finishes he will be a boxer to watch for..Peterson is still young in terms of what he has done in the ring and still has much to learn..I'm excited to see him fight tonight can't wait..

                    Comment

                    • IronDanHamza
                      BoxingScene Icon
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Oct 2009
                      • 49660
                      • 5,081
                      • 270
                      • 104,043

                      #60
                      I just re-scored it and have it 95-94 Ortiz.

                      Ortiz could arubally have sweeped the first 5 rounds plus the two KD's but I gave Round 2 to Peterson.

                      *I had round 5 an even round.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP