About the KHAN-MAIDANA Scoring...

[KJB]

113-112 is a ridiculous score, it wasnt that close. Khan won probably 8 rounds to 4, with each scoring a 10-8 round in the process, and Marocs losing a point for the elbow foul

Nah, you could easily score it six rounds a piece. I know several well educated fans who scored the fight 113-112 for Khan.

[iPhoneKiller]

that was my scorecard for the morales fight. can you read?

Oh I see, my bad. I read the last page of the quote. I didn't go through the thread and assumed it was Khan and Maidana.

[iPhoneKiller]

Nah, you could easily score it six rounds a piece. I know several well educated fans who scored the fight 113-112 for Khan.

I can believe a close score card, but not a win for Maidana.

Simply because all the rounds that Maidana could have won, were given to him in that score card.

[John Barron]

Oh I see, my bad. I read the last page of the quote. I didn't go through the thread and assumed it was Khan and Maidana.

ah ok.

I didn't see the fight been close that much, I had it 8-4 rounds for Khan, I scored the 10th round a 10-9 round to maidana, he didn't knock Khan down to deserve a 10-8 round and anyone scoring that a 10-8 round is just been generous to maidana.

khan was dominated and nearly out on his feet for 2 whole minutes of a 3 minute round...

[Ray*]

ah ok.


khan was dominated and nearly out on his feet for 2 whole minutes of a 3 minute round...

I disagree, He wasn't dominated for 2 minutes, He was definitely hurt, was on steady legs but was still moving and actually throwing back and landing, He didn't go down, but move around, scoring that a 10-8 round is ridiculous and generous to maidana, If we are going to be scoring rounds like that a 10-8 round then shame, am sure Mosley can claim a 10-8 round against Mayweather for hurting him..

[KJB]

I can believe a close score card, but not a win for Maidana.

Simply because all the rounds that Maidana could have won, were given to him in that score card.

Yeah, I agree with all of that.
That fight sure was an instant classic.

[shenmue]

The Myth about this fight is that Khan won the first 9 rounds, he didn't because Maidana should have won rounds 3,6 and 7 IMHO. Maidana won round 10 10-8 and you could give him rounds 11 and 12 but a lot of people think Khan won round 11 and they might be right.

Closer fight than most remember, a rematch would be great.

[adamk1304]

I scored it 114-111 for Khan, I think I gave Maidana five rounds with a 10-8 for round 10.

[lfc19titles]

I had khan winning the fight by 4 points in the end, he dominated the fight imo, the only reason it got close was because of his stamina and him being over trained, in the judah fight you can see he was in better shape

I hope khan fights maidana again, he will win again

[Ray*]

If you score round 11 and 12 to Maidana then you must either be crazy or from Team Maidana, the only round Maidana won clearly was round 10, Which was a 10-9 round, He also won round 3 on my card, the rest he was Outland while following Khan like a mummy, and when he does get close he would land the upper Cuton Khan but few..