About the KHAN-MAIDANA Scoring...

[John Barron]

If you score round 11 and 12 to Maidana then you must either be crazy or from Team Maidana, the only round Maidana won clearly was round 10, Which was a 10-9 round, He also won round 3 on my card, the rest he was Outland while following Khan like a mummy, and when he does get close he would land the upper Cuton Khan but few..

yeah, even the veteran judges ringside were from team maidana. come on man, a 10-9 for the 10th round is very debatable and so far, you're the only person i have come across to entertain this but, now you're also saying maidana won only 2 rounds that entire fight? be honest, how fresh is this fight in your memory?

what's next? ricky hatton was pitching an absolute shutout before he got knocked out in the 10th?

[shenmue]

yeah, even the veteran judges ringside were from team maidana. come on man, a 10-9 for the 10th round is very debatable and so far, you're the only person i have come across to entertain this but, now you're also saying maidana won only 2 rounds that entire fight? be honest, how fresh is this fight in your memory?

what's next? ricky hatton was pitching an absolute shutout before he got knocked out in the 10th?

Maidana won the 3rd which was close but I'm sure there were 2 middle rounds, i think 6 and 7 that were also Maidana rounds. Some people think Khan won the 11th round which is reasonable but i think round 12 is a Maidana round. Round 10 should be 10-8 to Maidana based on damage done to Khan its one of the most one sided rounds I've seen without a knockdown.

[John Barron]

here's the round by round scores of all 3 judges

Jerry Roth
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Maidana
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Khan

Total - 114-111

CJ Ross
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Khan
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Maidana

Total - 114-111

Glen Trowbridge
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Maidana
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Maidana

Total - 113-112

[John Barron]

Maidana won the 3rd which was close but I'm sure there were 2 middle rounds, i think 6 and 7 that were also Maidana rounds. Some people think Khan won the 11th round which is reasonable but i think round 12 is a Maidana round. Round 10 should be 10-8 to Maidana based on damage done to Khan its one of the most one sided rounds I've seen without a knockdown.

yup, 3 and 4 were close rounds, 6 and 7 khan faded as maidana became more consistent with the looping right hands and uppercuts, round 10 is a definite 10-8 and i gave khan the 11th on effective combinations. my round by rounds are a couple pages back.

[shenmue]

here's the round by round scores of all 3 judges

Jerry Roth
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Maidana
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Khan

Total - 114-111

CJ Ross
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Khan
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Maidana

Total - 114-111

Glen Trowbridge
Round 1. 10-8 Khan
Round 2. 10-9 Khan
Round 3. 10-9 Maidana
Round 4. 10-9 Khan
Round 5. 10-8 Khan
Round 6. 10-9 Maidana
Round 7. 10-9 Maidana
Round 8. 10-9 Khan
Round 9. 10-9 Khan
Round 10. 10-8 Maidana
Round 11. 10-9 Maidana
Round 12. 10-9 Maidana

Total - 113-112

That is interesting, If Jerry Roth gave the 12 round to Maidana like the other two judges did it would have been 113-112 on two scorecards making the Point deduction for Maidana stopping it from being a draw. And CJ Ross gave Khan round 6 which is a Maidana round IMO.

[The_Golden_Goy]

I think 90% of sensible people would have Khan winning this fight by at least 3 rounds, myself I had Khan winning 8-4 but I suppose people have different interpretations on very close rounds.

But i cannot understand someone who has Maidana winning the fight

[The_Golden_Goy]

That is interesting, If Jerry Roth gave the 12 round to Maidana like the other two judges did it would have been 113-112 on two scorecards making the Point deduction for Maidana stopping it from being a draw. And CJ Ross gave Khan round 6 which is a Maidana round IMO.

that is true, and quite interesting.

good shout

[shenmue]

I think 90% of sensible people would have Khan winning this fight by at least 3 rounds, myself I had Khan winning 8-4 but I suppose people have different interpretations on very close rounds.

But i cannot understand someone who has Maidana winning the fight

There's no way you could have Maidana winning the fight, 113-112 is the closest outcome because of the two 10 -8 rounds for Khan.

[The_Golden_Goy]

There's no way you could have Maidana winning the fight, 113-112 is the closest outcome because of the two 10 -8 rounds for Khan.

exactly.

great fight. rematch before Amir goes to 147.

if not maybe Marcos follows him up in weight to hunt down a rematch ala Marquez w/ Pacquiao

[shenmue]

exactly.

great fight. rematch before Amir goes to 147.

if not maybe Marcos follows him up in weight to hunt down a rematch ala Marquez w/ Pacquiao

I can't see Khan fighting the winner of Maidana vs Guerrero, i hope he does because it would be a great fight but i can see him fighting Morales for Bradley's vacated WBC title LOL.

But the winner of Maidana/Guerrero will get a title shot against someone anyway i hope.