Better Resume, Marquez or Cotto?

[jrosales13]

Juan Diaz lost to Campbell then beat Katsidis lost to Marquez. He lost twice to Paulie and got beat again by Marquez. Losing to Mayweather is better than losing to Campbell

And, he had a win after Campbell a good win over a top LW after Campbell. He had a good resume at LW a much better resume than Judah had at WW.

WTF did Judah did between Floyd and Cotto fights? Not a damn thing. He went 5 years without a win of note. 5 FUCKING years. Don't give me that BS man.

The Diaz win over the Judah win.

[uncle_ray]

JMM lineal champ in two divisions trumps cotto resume, easy.

I'm also PR and JMM is easily my favorite Mexican

[theplayerpimp]

JMM lineal champ in two divisions trumps cotto resume, easy.

I'm also PR and JMM is easily my favorite Mexican

Cotto never even unified any of belts. While marquez is the current lineal champ.

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

how the hell is resume=wins?

wins=wins.

resume=resume

losses=losses

Thank you, there are some real knuckleheads in this place.

Look, if you fought everyone and LOST to everyone, I can understand their point but using DLH as an example again, dude arguably beat Mosley and Trinidad.


You can't just dismiss those fights because he lost the decision....LOL

JMM has a better record against better fighters and is a more accomplished fighter, end of story. Cotto is good, JMM is great.

Now let's move on.

[solo20]

Orlando Salido beating Jumma and JMM beating him in his prime made his stock go up which led me to giving the nod to JMM over Cotto

[jrosales13]

JMM lineal champ in two divisions trumps cotto resume, easy.

I'm also PR and JMM is easily my favorite Mexican

JMM was only lineal champ in 1 division not two.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Is this a joke? its like comparing Muhammad Ali to Tyson Fury. Cotto should never be mentioned in the same breath as Marquez

[puga]

its about equal to me too but jmm edges it out just by a bit....

[revs1227]

jmm hands down

[figzuki]

I hands down agree its Marquez....

There are few people right now who could trump Cottos resume but Marquez is def one of them....