Better Resume, Marquez or Cotto?

[jrosales13]

I didn't say all that, all I'm saying is Judah brought more to the ring than Katsidis did against Marquez/ Diaz did against Marquez in the rematch. Judah was a tougher opponent in my opinion. Keep in mind, I'm not that impressed with Marquez's recent run, nor am I that impressed with Cotto's win over Judah. Just telling it as I see it. Yeah Judah's mental strength is meh...but Katsidis and Diaz have holes to their game as well

Do you think Judah wins is better than the first Diaz win?

[-DSG-]

its definetly close anyone who says otherwise is a fool

[Doctor_Tenma]

Do you think Judah wins is better than the first Diaz win?

Noppers

[brick wall]

resume = accomplishments

i give it to jmm but it's close. if wins matters and so are losses. cotto's 2 ko losses drags his resume down for me more than it affected jmm with his 3 losses which are close and debatable.

[joelab75]

WTF! JMM doesnt even have a good resume..what are u guys talking about? u guys are nuts..Cotto has way better resume than JMM..

JMM's best win was against a SHOT AND OLD Barrera.
JMM overrated..Diaz was promising but it doesnt mean he was going to be good..promising doesnt mean *****!!! Diaz is a bum..

Cotto's best win was against the best version of Mosley in recent years..

[ChampBox@PR]

resume=wins

jmm-casamayor,barrera,juan diaz,katsidas

cotto-judah,clottey,shane,,mallinaggi


id have to go with cotto....but jmm has accomplished more since hes been a linear champ in 2 divisions

It's close if you ask me.

You can make solid arguments for both guys.

Agree with both!!!!

[Picazo]

History books will say JMM, correct?

Lets ends this by asking who the better fighter is.

[Walt Liquor]

resume=wins

jmm-casamayor,barrera,juan diaz,katsidas

cotto-judah,clottey,shane,,mallinaggi


id have to go with cotto....but jmm has accomplished more since hes been a linear champ in 2 divisions

how the hell is resume=wins?

wins=wins.

resume=resume

losses=losses

[joelab75]

if JMM was so good he should have dominate a shot Barrera and chris john..but he didnt. it was both a close fights..not because he had 2 close fights against Pac doesnt mean he is up there with Pac..it was just a close fight..same with Castillo against Mayweather..

and please..the better fighter doesnt mean *****..its all about resume..lots of better fighters out there didnt make the hall of fame. or even dominate boxing..its all about winning the fight not the skills..

[Doctor_Tenma]

History books will say JMM, correct?

Lets ends this by asking who the better fighter is.

Marquez obviously, even though Cotto has some attributes Marquez lacks. Cotto hasn't been the same since Margarito though...

My only issue is when people say it ain't close, like I'm having a hard time picking one over the other.