Who has the better resume Sugar Ray Leonard or Manny Pacquiao?

[IronDanHamza]

puga, your major failing is that Leonard not only has better quality wins than Pacquiao, but has just as many or more meaningful wins.
Mayweather #5 at WW
Shields #3 at WW
Muniz #6 at WW
Gant #4 at WW
Ranzany #6 at WW
Price #10 at WW
Green #8 at WW
Kalule #1 at LMW
Finch #6 at WW
LaLonde #5 at LHW

add in his wins over Hearns, Duranx2, Benitez, and Hagler, and Leonard has just as many top quality wins as Pacquiao does, since Pacquiao has about 13 or so wins over top competition.

The guy is remarkably ******.

This should end the thread. Will it? No.

Because this moron will just reply with nonsense with very little meaning.

I am stopping now, the vast majority of this thread is sheer nonsense.

Although Leonard has dominated the Poll I am disgusted that Pac has 30% of the vote.

Sheer idiocy. Ah well.

[Eastbay Giant]

[puga]

puga, your major failing is that Leonard not only has better quality wins than Pacquiao, but has just as many or more meaningful wins.
Mayweather #5 at WW
Shields #3 at WW
Muniz #6 at WW
Gant #4 at WW
Ranzany #6 at WW
Price #10 at WW
Green #8 at WW
Kalule #1 at LMW
Finch #6 at WW
LaLonde #5 at LHW

add in his wins over Hearns, Duranx2, Benitez, and Hagler, and Leonard has just as many top quality wins as Pacquiao does, since Pacquiao has about 13 or so wins over top competition.

all of those aint worth talking about man...seroiusly...with the exeption of lalonde and kalule, none of those ever a held a world title.....

[Steak]

all of those aint worth talking about man...seroiusly...with the exeption of lalonde and kalule, none of those ever a held a world title.....

you are aware that in this day and age there are literally twice as many titles, correct? and they are meaningless?

example: Senchenko is the WBA WW champ. Clottey was not when Pacquiao beat him. what is the better win, over Senchenko or Clottey? obviously Clottey, since he is higher rated in the division, despite not holding a paper title.

[Cash Cow]

Obviously it's easily Leonard, Pacquiao has never beaten anyone nearly as good as Hearns, Hagler, Benitez, Duran, etc.

its simple....would Sugar Ray Leonard ever lose to Rustico Torrecampo or Medgoen Singsurat??

[puga]

you are aware that in this day and age there are literally twice as many titles, correct? and they are meaningless?

example: Senchenko is the WBA WW champ. Clottey was not when Pacquiao beat him. what is the better win, over Senchenko or Clottey? obviously Clottey, since he is higher rated in the division, despite not holding a paper title.

yes, i am aware.....but you are aware that leonard has held other title than wbc right?.....and you are aware that pac has won more LINEALtitles than leonard right?....and clottey wasnt at the time when pac fought him butthats still better than those guys you mentioned, becuase clottey was ww rated # 3 and a former world champion...

[Stromprophet]

puga, your major failing is that Leonard not only has better quality wins than Pacquiao, but has just as many or more meaningful wins.
Mayweather #5 at WW
Shields #3 at WW
Muniz #6 at WW
Gant #4 at WW
Ranzany #6 at WW
Price #10 at WW
Green #8 at WW
Kalule #1 at LMW
Finch #6 at WW
LaLonde #5 at LHW

add in his wins over Hearns, Duranx2, Benitez, and Hagler, and Leonard has just as many top quality wins as Pacquiao does, since Pacquiao has about 13 or so wins over top competition.

Got a source for Kalule being #1 in the world at LMW? (What is that? Light Middle? I think you mean JMW).

Not one of those guys is in the hall of fame are they? So again, what is the ranking of the opposition Manny is facing each time out?

Are you going to contend that they weren't fighters in the top 10 of the division Manny fought them in?

With the exception of Fahsan Por Thawatchai, I believe every single fight he's had since 2003 has been against someone who was top 10 in the division he fought them in.

I think you'll find Pac has 10 wins against guys who were #10 or better in the weight division. Again, once he has become a star, he has fought more people than SRL did for the rest of his career.

SRL fought 13 guys over 10 years. Manny has 18 over 7. So if you consider Manny has been fighting at this level since 2003 when he beat MAB. There's something to say for career length, activity, etc.

Again, I'm just pointing out it's not the blow out people seem to be in love with saying it is.

[The_Demon]

Leonard does,he has victories over 4 legit top 50 fighters of all time,pac hasnt had that type of comp too beat

[Stromprophet]

Everyone always uses duran as an example of how great he was,when in reality, duran was falling off when he fought sugar. I mean the very next fight after leonard ,he lost to pat lawlor, who is a nobody.

?

He didn't fight Pat Lawlor till 1991.

Leonard Rematched him right away after losing to him. While Duran had a very long career I don't think he was shot in the Leonard fight. He was 29 when they first met (which is older in hispanic boxing careers typically).

[Stromprophet]

Leonard does,he has victories over 4 legit top 50 fighters of all time,pac hasnt had that type of comp too beat

Manny has 2 over MAB, 2 over Morales. 1 over DLH. 1 (or 2) over JMM. All those guys are top 50. Some people don't add JMM, but I think he is.