Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Marquez>Ruiz. Not who fought them and where, just Marquez>Ruiz. Period. JMM is a better fighter than John Ruiz. RJJ fought the lesser fighter at the fighters best weight, Mayweather fought the better fighter at an uncomfortable weight class. I know that. But still Marquez>Ruiz, at the end of the day.

so if Floyd fought JuanMa while PAC moved up and fought someone like lets say Arthur Abraham, you would give Floyd more props....gotcha

[FerdinandMarcos]

Roy's secondary wins are better as well.

You don't even believe that.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Most people on this site didnt start watching Floyd until 2007.

[Steak]

Most people on this site didnt start watching Floyd until 2007.

in that case they also missed Roys entire career.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

in that case they also missed Roys entire career.

Good point......lol.


They both have excellent resumes. I give Floyd the edge.

[studentofthegam]

ever since 1990 w/e it was, jones from the very beggining always said, not the guys like lewis who are too big, but the tysons of the HW division

no one had a problem then, just the idea of a former junior middleweight going to heavyweight was mind blowing, when he does it years later, you're not impressed?

I never took away from the accomplishment but the conversation is about elite fighters and the doesnt include RUIZ. rIGHT OR wRONG?

[mannygati]

no way mayweather till this piont is better thn roy evr was roy was a ducker too and once they found roy is weak to the body it went down hill from there i havent seen mayweather on the verge of loosing a fight again i dnt like him his a pro ducker and his big mouth gets to me but the freaking guy is unhitable no joke way better then roy

[IMDAZED]

You don't even believe that.

Actually, I do.

[jrosales13]

I never took away from the accomplishment but the conversation is about elite fighters and the doesnt include RUIZ. rIGHT OR wRONG?

Ruiz is arguably a top 3 HW in the last decade.

And, was at his best when Roy fought him.

So yea....that win over Ruiz is just as good as Floyd greatest win which is Corrales.

[Walt Liquor]

so we all agree that roy has wins over better greater fighters (demolising toney and bhop and prob ruiz)

ok....

so take out floyd's best 3 wins out (corrales, castillo, zab or hatton)

does anyone really think that roy vs floyd taking out those 3 goes floyd's way? AND compensates for the fact that roy's best 3 wins are WAAAAAY better than floyd's?

and to say the jmm win was better than the ruiz win, should eliminate you from being able to post on boxingscene any longer