Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[THE REED]

Floyd went from weighing in at the WW limit of 147, to weighing 150 against Oscar...

Roy went from the LHW limit of 175 to weighing 193 at the weigh in and 199 on fight night... then back to 175.

[IMDAZED]

i stand corrected...i missed a class, cruiserweight. albeit a very easy class to miss. and he came in under the cruiser limit.

but i think moving up in weight slowed floyd down as well. maybe not as much as roy and the slow down would matter to roy anyways because his style relies heavily on his reflexes.

I think it was even worse for Roy who went down 20lbs and was going on 35.

[studentofthegam]

I'm going with Floyd:
Comparing wins:
Jose Luis Castillo < Toney
Jose Luis Castillo=Green Hopkins
Oscar De La Hoya=Ruiz
Shane Mosley=Virgil Hill
Zab Judah=Harding
Diego Corrales>Griffin
Ricky Hatton < Tarver

Noticable losses:
Tarver ko loss
Johnson ko loss
Tarver ud loss

Accomplishments:
Title defenses don't really mean much these days
5 division world champion > 4 division world champion

Nice break down but Hatton beats Tarver.

Floyd went from weighing in at the WW limit of 147, to weighing 150 against Oscar...

Roy went from the LHW limit of 175 to weighing 193 at the weigh in and 199 on fight night... then back to 175.

He had no business goin to HW. I think he went because he felt like he was losing it so he had target practice on Ruiz. We cant make excuses for ROy. If you notice we havent made any excuses for Floyd the whole thread.

[SCtrojansbaby]

I'm going with Floyd:
Comparing wins:
Jose Luis Castillo < Toney
Jose Luis Castillo=Green Hopkins
Oscar De La Hoya=Ruiz
Shane Mosley=Virgil Hill
Zab Judah=Harding
Diego Corrales>Griffin
Ricky Hatton < Tarver

Noticable losses:
Tarver ko loss
Johnson ko loss
Tarver ud loss

Accomplishments:
Title defenses don't really mean much these days
5 division world champion > 4 division world champion

This is the most ******ed post I have ever seen

Try actually comparing there best wins dummy

Toney>>>>>Corralles
Hopkins>>>>>>>>>>>Hatton
Hill>>>>>>>Hernandez
McCcallum=DLH
Griffin>>>>>>>>close win against Castillo in rematch
Ruiz>Marquez JMM is obviously a 10x better fighter but Floyd weighed like 20 pounds more
Harding>>>>>>>>>basically a draw against Castillo in the first fight

[THE REED]

Nice break down but Hatton beats Tarver.

He had no business goin to HW. I think he went because he felt like he was losing it so he had target practice on Ruiz. We cant make excuses for ROy. If you notice we havent made any excuses for Floyd the whole thread.

He went to HW because he wanted to win a HW title.. not because he thought he was losing it

To this day he doesn't think he lost anything.

[THE REED]

Nice break down but Hatton beats Tarver.

Not the WW Hatton.

If Floyd fought Hatton at JR WW... possibly.

[V.WEBB]

He went to HW because he wanted to win a HW title.. not because he thought he was losing it

To this day he doesn't think he lost anything.

Right, which is why he is still fighting. But, I love to hear Roy call a fight though.

[Haglerwins]

man.. if Roy retired after Tarver 1 this wouldn't be a discussion at all.

He would've been the most heralded fighter since Leonard.

[Walt Liquor]

Nice break down but Hatton beats Tarver.

He had no business goin to HW. I think he went because he felt like he was losing it so he had target practice on Ruiz. We cant make excuses for ROy. If you notice we havent made any excuses for Floyd the whole thread.

you're kidding right?

[SirTomJones]

Jose Luis Castillo < Toney?????????

No way!

Knocking out Malinga impressed me too