Since we're on the subject. Better Resume Floyd or Roy?

[Las Vegas,]

Roy - James Toney, Vinny Paz, Gonzalez, Hopkins, Ruiz, Tarver, Trinidad.

Floyd - Hernandez, Corrales, Castillo twice, Manfredy, Gatti, Judah, De La Hoya, Hatton, and Mosley.

I don't know about you, but Floyd has a better resume. I don't care if you include that "Castillo beat Floyd" because Tarver beat Jones, and taking that win away from Jones and he gets blown away.

Roy was obviously the more talented fighter, but he was the FIRST EVER, media hyped cherry picker.

[Kagami Taiga]

i was a hardcore boxing fan and maybe a teen heard that but that's not what the folks who knew what they were talking about were saying.

baldo was supposed to be a tuneup for zab, sh it he was already signed for the floyd fight

im not saying it was a great win. it was an ok win that gained the lineal status. either way, i was a teen but i def was a hardcore fan. my fav fighter at the time was winky wright.

[FerdinandMarcos]

Baldomir is an OK win. Hes someone who just kind of stumbled across the lineal title, even though in reality he isnt that awesome of a fighter(even though he won it legitimately). Kind of like Billy Backus, but at least Backus beat an ATG in Napoles.(albeit via cut stoppage).

fact is Baldomir didnt do jack **** after Mayweather beat him.

I give credit to Mayweather for beating Baldomir, but not a huge amount. it would have been better if Mayweather beat Cotto or Margarito

as for Judah...its a solid win. Judah is one of those guys that always gives fighters trouble at least for a little bit, but the thing is he did lose to a number of other fighters, most notably at WW(Cotto, Clottey, Spinks, Baldomir).

Your memory is shot to hell..

When Floyd fought Baldomir...

Cotto was still getting wobbled at 140 and Tony was hiding in WBO-land fighting the likes of Manuel Gomez and the dreaded Hercules Keyvelos.

Damn you Floyd Mayweather for not dropping everything to fight a slow-ass mofo that couldn't even beat an out of shape Daniel Santos..


Brian Kenny said Floyd was going to duck Baldomir.

[FerdinandMarcos]

Haha, I remember this. "Why aren't you fighting the guy who beat Zab?" "Why aren't you fighting the legitimate WW champion?" "Why aren't you fighting Baldomir are you scared of him?" Then after Floyd answered all Brian Kenny's questions...ESPN:"FLOYD FOUGHT A BUM WITH 9 LOSES!" lol.

LOL

I remember it too.

[Steak]

Your memory is shot to hell..

When Floyd fought Baldomir...

Cotto was still getting wobbled at 140 and Tony was hiding in WBO-land fighting the likes of Manuel Gomez and the dreaded Hercules Keyvelos.

Damn you Floyd Mayweather for not dropping everything to fight a slow-ass mofo that couldn't even beat an out of shape Daniel Santos..


Brian Kenny said Floyd was going to duck Baldomir.

Cotto won the WBA title dominating Quintana a month after Floyd-Baldomir, and Margarito had a few title defenses already and had beaten Cintron.

I would have liked to see Mayweather fight one of them after or before Baldomir, and in hindsight obviously both those wins would have been more respected than Floyd's win over Baldomir. can you really argue against that?

[studentofthegam]

first off, zab has ALWAYS been overrated. look what kostya did to him. look what clottey and cotto did to him. look what the slowest no poerest having lineal cham ever did to him.

cotto and clottey damn near killed zab.

zab was quick enough to catch cory but other than that, he's NOTHING at ww. have you ever looked at his WW resume? it's a quarter step aboive rafael pineda's

Kostya ended a lot of fights early. Zab had Tszyu in trouble and his immaturaty kept him from getting a chance to continue. Cotto is a Hall of Famer. Now its no reason on paper he should have lost to Baldo but **** happens. A hard head will take you a long way in boxing. Im not say beating Zab should be over glorified victory but its solid. Not "Well he beat Zab but...." . But what?

[Steak]

Roy - James Toney, Vinny Paz, Gonzalez, Hopkins, Ruiz, Tarver, Trinidad.

Floyd - Hernandez, Corrales, Castillo twice, Manfredy, Gatti, Judah, De La Hoya, Hatton, and Mosley.

I don't know about you, but Floyd has a better resume. I don't care if you include that "Castillo beat Floyd" because Tarver beat Jones, and taking that win away from Jones and he gets blown away.

Roy was obviously the more talented fighter, but he was the FIRST EVER, media hyped cherry picker.

Roy also has wins over Jorge Fernando Castro, Reggie Johnson, Harding, Hill, Griffin, and Woods. I wouldnt count Roy's win over Trinidad personally.

Floyd also has good wins over Chavez and and Corley that you ignored.

[Las Vegas,]

Roy also has wins over Jorge Fernando Castro, Reggie Johnson, Harding, Hill, Griffin, and Woods. I wouldnt count Roy's win over Trinidad personally.

Floyd also has good wins over Chavez and and Corley that you ignored.

Sorry, I made the list on pure memory. Forgot about Chavez, even though I was there live.

[Walt Liquor]

Your memory is shot to hell..

When Floyd fought Baldomir...

Cotto was still getting wobbled at 140 and Tony was hiding in WBO-land fighting the likes of Manuel Gomez and the dreaded Hercules Keyvelos.

Damn you Floyd Mayweather for not dropping everything to fight a slow-ass mofo that couldn't even beat an out of shape Daniel Santos..


Brian Kenny said Floyd was going to duck Baldomir.

Hey memory man, who had the most defenses of a ww title at that time by far?

[Walt Liquor]

Kostya ended a lot of fights early. Zab had Tszyu in trouble and his immaturaty kept him from getting a chance to continue. Cotto is a Hall of Famer. Now its no reason on paper he should have lost to Baldo but **** happens. A hard head will take you a long way in boxing. Im not say beating Zab should be over glorified victory but its solid. Not "Well he beat Zab but...." . But what?

And clottey. Zab was a huge underachiever.

Ow he's becoming an overachiever cuz he's fighting back at his best weight. Zab's. Ww record is like .500, is that really a great win for Floyd?