Martinez is seriously making his case as No. 1 P4P

[.::|ULTIMATE|::.]

Martinez is #1

[Canelo Phresh]

My problem with this is you guys need to set some type of parameter and stick to it. As soon as something disproves your argument, you guys switch it up to fit an agenda.

Which one is it?

Is it what have you done lately, or are we gonna do it like it's always been done and judge a fighters body of work over the past 2-3 years

As soon as you pick one then I will proceed to rip your logic to pieces.

recently. the last year and change because if you want to go the last 2 to 3 years then you start offering an atg argument then you can logically explain why inactive mayweather is number 2.

[Khalid X]

top rank wont let jccj near martinez. cotto is gonna rematch marg dont play ******. and your once again offering a career is better argument than timing argument on margarito. sorry but margarito at 154lbs after a ko loss year suspension and a gone the distance fight with club fighter garcia is not etter than dzinzuruk. you *******s live in an imaginary world where pac faced the margarito fresh off of the cotto victory and cotto fresh off the mosley victory and etc etc etc. timing is important in when you fight a great fighter not just that you fought him at the ends of their careers.

And you live in an imaginary world in which Martinez faced Pavlik just after he beat Taylor twice and Dzin coming fresh off his wins against Santos.

Again that same logic can be applied Marintez opponents because outside of getting dominated by Hopkins, Pav hasn't done ****
and in the past three years Dzin has only beaten mediocre fighters in Dawson and Julio. Dzin has been severly inactive so according to your own "what have you done lately" logic, Martinez wins over both don't mean much.....

[War Dinamita]

You're an idiot. That just like 1/4 of Pac's entire career. And Again cotto, clottey and margarito are actually still considered top fighters at each of there weight classes.

Clottey and Margacheato are still considered top fighters in boxing? Please get off your knees and stop sucking Pac's ****.

[ThePrince]

timing is important in when you fight a great fighter not just that you fought him at the ends of their careers.

Ok, so what about the timing of fighting Dzinziruk at 160 makes it worthy of being P4P #1?

You say Margarito was a has been but Dzinziruk is a never was... and a LMW.

I'm done with this ******ed circlejerk. Just going to let you know that you should probably prepare yourself emotionally for Monday when the rankings from ESPN, RING, Yahoo, etc come out and The Congressman is sitting pretty at the top as usual and Sergio is holding down number 3 like a G

[Canelo Phresh]

And you live in an imaginary world in which Martinez faced Pavlik just after he beat Taylor twice and Dzin coming fresh off his wins against Santos.

please just offer your argument why pacs recent resume is better than sergios. ill never attack pacs victory over hatton and by your logic pacs victory over hatton is irrelevant because of how lack luster he was after mayweather knocked him out. im not arguing atg status im arguing p4p status. be consistant and offer your true logic as to why pacquiao is still p4p over sergio.

[Khalid X]

Clottey and Margacheato are still considered top fighters in boxing? Please get off your knees and stop sucking Pac's ****.

And Pavlik and Dzin were when Martinez beat them?

[memento126]

Martinez should be P4P number one fighter in the world. I like Pacquiao but Sergio has been fighting better opposition than Pac in his last 4 fights. He is the real deal I don't see anyone beating him anytime soon.

My list for top 5 fighters
1. Sergio Martinez
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Nonito Donaire
5. Timothy Bradley
6. Wladimir Klitchko
I would put Floyd in there but he is inactive and I don't think he will fight anytime soon.
Also didn't put Andre Ward because he is just one dirty mofo thats not boxing to me.

[Canelo Phresh]

Ok, so what about the timing of fighting Dzinziruk at 160 makes it worthy of being P4P #1?

You say Margarito was a has been but Dzinziruk is a never was... and a LMW.

I'm done with this ******ed circlejerk. Just going to let you know that you should probably prepare yourself emotionally for Monday when the rankings from ESPN, RING, Yahoo, etc come out and The Congressman is sitting pretty at the top as usual and Sergio is holding down number 3 like a G

yeah there p4p lists will still be pac 1 may 2 until those 2 either fight or retire because of what that potnential fight means for the sport not because they are fighting relevant opponents anymore.

[$coinblatt$]

Martinez is a BEAST definitely P4P....