True or False: Pacquiao's Welter Resume>>>Floyd's

[lfc19titles]

They're both pretty weak when it comes to welter resumes. Floyd has held the linear title twice but his other opposition is pretty wack. Pacquiao's been opportunistic. Neither are that impressive at welter.

i would agree to that but one thing which does it for me is the way floyd went about it

the real solid wins in my opinion are cotto and clottey

there may be 1 or 2 solid wins on floyds as well but he had the chance when he was in his prime to fight to top guys and just avoided them when they were at their so called prime

cotto, margarito and mosley why oh why did he not push for these fights is beyond me

pac came to welter and the best outside of floyd was cotto and mosley, he took cotto out while floyd eventually got to mosley

neither is greatly impressive, in comparisons to the barrera, morales and marquez at 130, pacs welter resume is pissssssssss poor but you can only beat what is put in front of you

[IMDAZED]

i would agree to that but one thing which does it for me is the way floyd went about it

the real solid wins in my opinion are cotto and clottey

there may be 1 or 2 solid wins on floyds as well but he had the chance when he was in his prime to fight to top guys and just avoided them when they were at their so called prime

cotto, margarito and mosley why oh why did he not push for these fights is beyond me

pac came to welter and the best outside of floyd was cotto and mosley, he took cotto out while floyd eventually got to mosley

neither is greatly impressive, in comparisons to the barrera, morales and marquez at 130, pacs welter resume is pissssssssss poor but you can only beat what is put in front of you

Clottey is not a solid win and even less of a solid win than Baldomir. Cotto is a solid win. Mosley was a solid win.

[Twako]

Baldomir was definitely a better win than Cotto and Clottey combined:

omfg you cant be serious...

ppl like you think pac will demolish cotto even at 154, so why would you think ONE ****ing LB will make a difference when cotto was 146 in his last fight?

[lfc19titles]

Clottey is not a solid win and even less of a solid win than Baldomir. Cotto is a solid win. Mosley was a solid win.

maybe but thats just me, I kind of see clottey as the high risk low reward fighter, very underrated imo

[IMDAZED]

maybe but thats just me, I kind of see clottey as the high risk low reward fighter, very underrated imo

Has one decent win over a much faded Judah. Also lost to Baldomir. Nothing special about that cat. He's a good loser, that's it.

[Heeb]

Floyd's is better, but neither is particularly great.

[IronDanHamza]

maybe but thats just me, I kind of see clottey as the high risk low reward fighter, very underrated imo

I would go with low risk low reward.

[TOBYLEE1]

Pacquiao's WW resume (2 years):

De La Hoya (Super Welter, 150 CW fight before Pac)
Cotto
Clottey
Margarito (150 CW, but we've been told over and over again Pac's 8th divisional belt is not legit and Tony was just a blown up welter)
Mosley

Floyd's WW resume (6 years):

Mitchell
Judah
Baldomir
Hatton (light-welter)
JMM (lightweight)
Mosley

So who has the better WW resume? Vote and discuss.

*Just for argument's sake, let's assume Pac wins against Mosley*

Don't know why are you counting Mosley for Pac cause they still haven't fought. You put it there so it could look better on Pac's resume.

All the fighters that you listed lost against either fighter so putting Mosley in Pac's list makes no sense

[Joartcc7]

Ladies and gentlemen.

So far 23 moronic creatures had the lack of brain and voted for Floyd. *****s will be *****s.

And one particular ***** even had the utter ignorance to compare Baldomir and COtto.

***** ignorance is really amazing by the day.

[mathed]

Pacquiao and Mayweather are both great in there own way.

There is no need to talk down on either fighter.
They both have done well at welterweight or any other weight they ever fought at.

Great post...both guys are excellent in the ring. Character aside, these are the two most skilled guys in the sport.