Who would you rank higher All-Time P4P; Duran, Pacquiao, or Chavez

[NChristo]

Honestly if we are talking about p4p (effectiveness in different weight classes) then it's

All-Time
1. Henry Armstrong
2. Ray Robinson
3. Manny Pacquiao

Again ATG and P4P ATG are two different things. If this is "Who is higher on the ATG list" then I agree Duran is higher as I have him easily in the top 10.

No Sam Langford ?.

[JaguarMNH]

When we say ALL TIME, then a World Record should be the Main Criteria!

Pacman holds the World Record (7 Titles in different weight divisions), That Duran and Chavez failed to do!

Pacman was voted "Fighter of the Decade" by BWAA, that Duran and Chaves wasn’t able to get.

Pacman Resume is much better than Duran and Chavez

If you wanna go by records, Chavez holds the records for most title defenses (27), most title fights (37), most title fight victories (31), most title defenses won by KO (21), and the longest winning streak in boxing history. (89 fights in 13 years)


With that said, P4P: DURAN

[NChristo]

If you wanna go by records, Chavez holds the records for most title defenses (27), most title fights (37), most title fight victories (31), most title defenses won by KO (21), and the longest winning streak in boxing history. (89 fights in 13 years)


With that said, P4P: DURAN

Jimmy Wilde went undefeated in 103 bouts.

[Russian Crushin]

Lol my bad if I came across as a **** i was just pissed because one of the discs for my Pacquiao set didn't work and I gotta wait 2 weeks to resume whatching his carreer.

lol nah you didnt and yea that sucks dude since you cant just skip over the fights that dont work. They DVDs or Downloaded fights?

[Russian Crushin]

If you wanna go by records, Chavez holds the records for most title defenses (27), most title fights (37), most title fight victories (31), most title defenses won by KO (21), and the longest winning streak in boxing history. (89 fights in 13 years)


With that said, P4P: DURAN

DAMN!!!!!!!

[Khalid X]

No Sam Langford ?.

My bad bro....I forgot about him as I go off the dome most of the time I post. I'm might have to back track with my post because for him to go from fighting LW's to fighting HW is pretty impressive. Not only that but to give up the weight he did in a lot of those fights was very impressive.

Again...let me back track with my post...lol

[Viciousz]

lol nah you didnt and yea that sucks dude since you cant just skip over the fights that dont work. They DVDs or Downloaded fights?

They're DVDs. I got like 30 sets and have only watched like 5 lol. But I don't like to skip fights I want to watch them all in chronological order so I can keep with the fighters career. You collect any?

[Viciousz]

BTW I think the real question here is whos better ATG-P4P Pacquiao or Chavez. Since Chavez is like number 14 in Bert Sugars Top 100 greatest fighters of all-time. And Duran was like 8 if I remember correctly.

[Viciousz]

Have to disagree, between Duran, Benny Leonard and Joe Gans I really can't decide who is the number 1, all of them have a very strong case.

It's too close to say either of them is "easily" the greatest lightweight.

What sucks about that is the fact there is very little footage of B. Leonard and Gans, but I would find it hard to believe they had a higher intensity in the ring then Duran.

[JaguarMNH]

Jimmy Wilde went undefeated in 103 bouts.

We both made a mistake. Wilde went undefeated in 103 bouts but it wasn't a win streak because he had multiple draws in those 103 bouts. So Chavez still has the longest winning streak but its 87 not 89