The Oscar who beat Mayorga would have beaten Margarito

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

Oscar's left hook would have landed far too many times, for Margraito to be able to see the final bell.

^^ Exactly this.


2006 JMW DLH >>>>> Margarito.


Knocks him out.

[MACAQUEINBLACK]

Oscar fought Forbes in 2008, coming down in weight.


I don't think that fight proves anything about how he would have done against Margarito @ 154 a year or two prior.


Oscar would have teed off.

[Hi-Dro]

2006/ beating the 2006 Margarito?

That version of Oscar would never have beaten any version of Margarito from 2005-2009. Maybe that version of Oscar beats the version of Margarito post Shane but that is about it. You would need a prime Oscar or a green Margarito to have Oscar win that fight.

dude you're one of the biggest oscar haters on this site...

when it comes to oscar im not listening to your biased ass...


no offense...

that oscar would have outboxed margarito and probably ko like mosley did. remember at the time no1 thought mosley would ko marg b4 u tell me no.

[Hi-Dro]

That 2006/2007 version of Oscar defense really wasn't there. The Forbes fight proved it, the Sturm fight proved it, and the Floyd fight proved it. You want to **** on Margarito defense but Oscar defense especially that version of Oscar was non existent as well. He probably showed against Mayorga like he still had it but he really didn't. That was a mirage, he just took one of Tito left overs who's chin was ruined by Tito. Something that Oscar has been doing for over 10 years taking on Tito left overs who get their chin cracked by Tito.

That version of Oscar was not a top fighter. Floyd and Shane were full time fighters. Oscar was a part time fighter full time promoter. That is the difference between those 3. Yes Shane did it and yes Floyd could of. But, the fact is that they were full time fighters and worked hard in the gym. While Oscar wasn't at all.

Oscar would not have KO'd Manny pretty easy. 6 or 7 years ago man. Unless if you talking about the version of Manny 6 or 7 years ago who was a at 126. I mean that would of been a pretty big jump for Manny. Lets use common sense here.

Lets be real he didn't beat Tito. Even if you had Oscar winning it was a close fight that could of gone either way.

Shane out hustled and out worked Oscar and Shane won the rematch. This is not an amateur is a professional fight. Judge it as a pro's not as ams.

He went up to MW and got a gift decision one of many that he has gotten in his career.

Lets not forget that this versions of Oscar in sparring was getting schooled by Little Ivan Calderon who is 5ft and 108 pounds. He couldn't even lay a glove on Calderon. And, also was getting beat up by Ortiz and really beat up by Valero.

Oscar is the most overrated fighter in the last 10 years not named Judah.

i said the 1 who beat mayo....

the forbes fight was after he got beat by may....


come on dude...marg ko oscar? that's hilarious..if any1 would be koing any1 in that fight it would be oscar ko marg

[Hi-Dro]

You're a good poster J, but I don't take anything serious that you say when it comes to Oscar, from your avatar to your sig plain Oscar hate. Kinda sad because Oscar was a very good fighter who fought everybody in his prime.

lol i wrote the same exact **** b4 i read this...

so im not the only1 who realizes jro is a huge oscar hater

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Margarito doesnt stand a chance vs. Oscar. Lets be serious people.

[KingTito]

Oscar wouldv'e whooped Tony.

[Hi-Dro]

You know I got love for you Jro, but you are blinded by hate when it comes to Oscar.

The version of Oscar that fought Floyd beats, and could quite possibly stop any version of Margarito.

You're a good poster J, but I don't take anything serious that you say when it comes to Oscar, from your avatar to your sig plain Oscar hate. Kinda sad because Oscar was a very good fighter who fought everybody in his prime.

dude you're one of the biggest oscar haters on this site...

when it comes to oscar im not listening to your biased ass...


no offense...

that oscar would have outboxed margarito and probably ko like mosley did. remember at the time no1 thought mosley would ko marg b4 u tell me no.

[infamous larryx]

floyd didnt duck margo..lol..he knew he had one fight left and wanted to cashout..its buisness

[infamous larryx]

Because, Oscar knew he couldn't beat Margarito. Oscar would had to turn back the hands of time so he could beat in his prime for him to win against Margarito.

and you say im a **** poster??lol..oscar wouldve destroyed tony..he didnt duck him..he wanted one last fight for alot of money..and margo doesnt bring big numbers