The Oscar who beat Mayorga would have beaten Margarito

[Canelo Phresh]

the 06 oscar vs margo with or with out plaster?

[jrosales13]

the 06 oscar vs margo with or with out plaster?

With plaster Margarito obliterates Oscar face. i would pay double for this and he would retire Oscar.

Without plaster either Oscar wins a controversial decision or losses a decision and in the post fight will cry and say that this is killing the sport and he will fix it by doing an investigation.

[Hi-Dro]

I dont think anyone has said hes the same. However that version would still beat Margarito IMO. Oscar beats him up pretty bad. Hes too damn slow and easy to hit to beat Oscar.

thats what im saying.

how is it difficult to comprehend? I implied that in my thread title...

jro let the non-biased folks speak...

when it comes to oscar you're as useless as burner when it comes to pwill...


you're going to hate the **** out of oscar and burner is going to suck the cum out of pwill...

[Canelo Phresh]

With plaster Margarito obliterates Oscar face. i would pay double for this and he would retire Oscar.

Without plaster either Oscar wins a controversial decision or losses a decision and in the post fight will cry and say that this is killing the sport and he will fix it by doing an investigation.

jro you got a great sense of humor but i think your right.

[Hi-Dro]

With plaster Margarito obliterates Oscar face. i would pay double for this and he would retire Oscar.

Without plaster either Oscar wins a controversial decision or losses a decision and in the post fight will cry and say that this is killing the sport and he will fix it by doing an investigation.

A prime oscar would kill margo...


the oscar who beat mayo would also kill him... he's to fast, precise, and technically superior compared to margarito...

Oscar has a far better chin then Margarito...he has taken punches from the best and has never been knocked out..

margarito got ktfo by a fighter oscar beat in the second fight

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Like Castillejo? I don't think Oscar "beat him pretty bad" I mean Castillejo was too damn slow and easy to hit.

Or cuz of what he did to Tito left overs like Campas, Vargas, and Mayorga. Especially Vargas and Mayorga who got their chin crack by Tito.

Or cuz Floyd and Hopkins decided to coast and carry Oscar?

Or cuz of Oscar gift decision?

Or cuz Oscar was competitive with Shane at 154? Who did Shane beat that was any good at 154 anyways?

Or was it something else that Oscar accomplish that I am missing since moving up to 154?

Matter of fact what heavy handed, volume punching, pressure fighter with a granite chin. Did Oscar fight in the last 10 years?

I think in your post you are focusing more on what Oscar cant do or havent done instead of what Margarito and Oscar bring to the table style wise. We cant sit here and act like Oscar is a bum and that he wasnt ever a good fighter. I dont like him and I dont think es an ATG but he was pretty good.

At 154 I didnt like how Marg looked in the Santos fight. Hell I want even that impressed with him in his last fight at 154. Style wise I dont see how this match up favors Margarito at all.

What can Marg do that Mayorga couldnt? I think Mayo is bigger, stronger and hits harder then Margarito. He got handled in 6 rounds with ease.

Margarito is a slow starter a very slow starter. Oscar could just coast the first couple of rounds without wasting too much energy then when Marg wants to turn it up Oscar will still have stamina. Against Mayweather Oscar didnt land ONE left hook... Margarito wont be so lucky.

Oscar will stick him with the jab and lace him with left hooks. Even that version of Oscar is way faster than Marg and still the much better boxer. Not to mention Oscar has a rock soild chin. Oscar would be the bigger, stronger, faster, and more skilled boxer if he ever fought Margarito. Outside of a lucky punch I dont see how Marg can win. Im talking styles. Just look at the style match up. Marg gets outboxed.

[jrosales13]

thats what im saying.

how is it difficult to comprehend? I implied that in my thread title...

jro let the non-biased folks speak...

when it comes to oscar you're as useless as burner when it comes to pwill...


you're going to hate the **** out of oscar and burner is going to suck the cum out of pwill...

Ok that is funny

But, still you guys are making it seem like a part time fighter, full time promoter would easily beat Margarito. There is a reason why he ducked him... There is a reason why he even offered Winky Wright 6 million but didn't offer Marg anything ever... Can't say that Winky brought in more money then Marg cuz that is not true.

Not saying that Marg is better than Winky, not saying that at all. Not even saying that Oscar. But, even if Oscar beat Marg he would suffer more physical damage in a win against Marg then he would in a dominating lost against Winky. And, Oscar knew that... There is a reason why he didn't ever wanted to fight Margarito.

[jrosales13]

A prime oscar would kill margo...


the oscar who beat mayo would also kill him... he's to fast, precise, and technically superior compared to margarito...

Oscar has a far better chin then Margarito...he has taken punches from the best and has never been knocked out..

margarito got ktfo by a fighter oscar beat in the second fight

Is the Oscar that fought Shane the same Oscar that fought Mayo?

And, also could it be safe to say that with all the shots that Marg took against Cotto took something away from him?

[Young Mike]

He wouldn't have beaten the Plaster Margarito, but he surely would've beaten the one Mosley beat.

[Hi-Dro]

no they're not the same jro but thats not the point...
my emphasis is on mosley in that scenerio and oscar and margs chin...

marg took those shots against cotto because his defense is ****....


the oscar who beat mayo was stronger, bigger, and faster then cotto with an arguable better jab...

he would have beat marg pre-cotto, and post cotto


honestly im not a fan of oscar and i feel your dislike towards him yet i still recognize that he was a very good boxer...even as a part time fighter