Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He wins and then drops over 6 places in the P4P list? That's ******ed.

I agree with you on that.

Till Hopkins loses he still P4P caliber. This list is just plain ******ed!!

[Heru]

BS has one of the best P4P lists out, clearly better than The Ring's right now.

[street bully]

BS has one of the best P4P lists out, clearly better than The Ring's right now.

You think that if a fighter wins a wide UD, albiet a horrible ight due to a ba style clash that they should drop over 6 spot? That is sovething you do to someone who was afluke P4Per who gets KOed in the first round.

And then we have mayweather retiring, and then leapfrogging everyone.

[FaustoGeraci]

Nice response fool. That's why nobody takes you serious around here. You can't even discuss boxing. You're just a flag waving, pom pom waving cheerleading ****rider. It's embarrassing.

[street bully]

Nice response fool. That's why nobody takes you serious around here. You can't even discuss boxing. You're just a flag waving, pom pom waving cheerleading ****rider. It's embarrassing.

Actually, other than Cotto, his P4P list is pretty good.

[FaustoGeraci]

Actually, other than Cotto, his P4P list is pretty good.

No Paul Williams in the top 10? But Bernard Hopkins is? What are you high? Or what?

[street bully]

No Paul Williams in the top 10? But Bernard Hopkins is? What are you high? Or what?

Um Hopkins was rated number 4 a week ago, and number 3 a few months ago. Winning fights do not move you out of the P4P lists, especialy very wide wins. Geting hit upside the head by martinez got Williams up the P4P list?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Nice response fool. That's why nobody takes you serious around here. You can't even discuss boxing. You're just a flag waving, pom pom waving cheerleading ****rider. It's embarrassing.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Um Hopkins was rated number 4 a week ago, and number 3 a few months ago. Winning fights do not move you out of the P4P lists, especialy very wide wins. Geting hit upside the head by martinez got Williams up the P4P list?

Co sign!!!!!!!!!!

[Heru]

You think that if a fighter wins a wide UD, albiet a horrible ight due to a ba style clash that they should drop over 6 spot? That is sovething you do to someone who was afluke P4Per who gets KOed in the first round.

And then we have mayweather retiring, and then leapfrogging everyone.

JMM's only been clearly beaten by 1 fighter in a fight where he had to go up 2 full weight classes and he dropped from #2 to 6 on most everybodies list.

Hopkins was facing a shot fighter got knocked out in 1 round the fight before by a non P4P level fighter, Roy threw half the punches he did and Hopkins could never even come close to taking him out. I bet on the under, he lost me money too, so **** his spot.

I wouldn't have taken him completely off, but other than his exclusion and some minor placement, this list is good.