Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[ShoulderRoll]

Was Pacquiao born in America? Why is it that he is #1 on this list?

[bojangles1987]

That's pretty much how I would make the p4p list look. Except that I really wonder why Chris John doesn't ever get on the p4p list.

[bojangles1987]

With OLYMPHIC GOLD MEDAL and perfect record 54(48)-3(3)-0 current Heavyweight KING Vladimir Klichko must be undisputed one of the best boxers of current time in any rating. What is wrong?I know what.May be UKRANIAN PASSPORTS?Klichko brothers must be borned in United States to get in this ****TY P4P rating?

Skillwise and athletically from p4p sense, the Klitschkos are far inferior fighters to these guys in the top 10. That's true about most heavyweights all time. If there were a heavyweight equivalent of a Manny Pacquiao in the heavyweight division the Klitschkos would get knocked out in 4 or 5 rounds.

[lfc19titles]

With OLYMPHIC GOLD MEDAL and perfect record 54(48)-3(3)-0 current Heavyweight KING Vladimir Klichko must be undisputed one of the best boxers of current time in any rating. What is wrong?I know what.May be UKRANIAN PASSPORTS?Klichko brothers must be borned in United States to get in this ****TY P4P rating?

how is that a perfect record?

he has beaten joke fighters and even got knocked out by joke fighters. he doesnt deserve to be in the top 10.

[kingfaze19]

this dumb author says bhop doesnt deserve it but puts marquez and mayweather is still number 2 , i never understood that, he came back to fight a blown up 135lb fighter and didnt even make the agreed catchweight of 144, why not remove him ? oh because he has the big name right ?

bhop resume has jones(twice), pavlik, calzaghe, tarver, trinidad, de la hoya, winky, taylor(twice).. come on he should be number 2 p4p behind manny pacquiao, thats the only spot that cant be argued with.

ok the fight on saturday wasnt that exciting, but bhop just wanted a W over jones, and he got it , point blank period. bhop never ducks nobody. it took a earthquake in haiti to happen for floyd to face a legit welterweight, he bitchhed out the fight vs manny.

1. pacquiao
2. hopkins
3. williams
4. mosley
5. w.klitschko (i dont know why HW never on the p4p list)
6. mayweather
7. dawson
8. v. klitschko
9. jm marquez
10. andre berto

[Kayoer]

ShoulderRoll-It's really funny how American promoters trying to make the boxer from Philippines an American hero,Idol.Real Americans does not care about Pokemon.I know that.Another reason-Pokemon fighting in States last 5 years. And HBO heeds Stars in the bag, and they made a star from Pokemon.

[rod_serrs]

i like the klitchkos but their current competetion is historically ****ty. no way to know how good they truly are, so they don't belong in the top 10 P4P list.

You can't blame them for that. They fight all their mandatory opponents, look for big fights, and do what they have to do. Their talent is far above the current talent pool but that should be no reason to penalize them.

[lfc19titles]

You can't blame them for that. They fight all their mandatory opponents, look for big fights, and do what they have to do. Their talent is far above the current talent pool but that should be no reason to penalize them.

you can only be judged if you beat good boxers. there are no big fights, only one is haye. when they faced decent boxers they lost

[Kayoer]

bojangles1987 Your guesses based on your imagination Vladimir Klichko is a heavyweight equivalent of Pokemon

[boxing_great]

**** I didn't know calderon is 35! he looks more like 20!