Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[FaustoGeraci]

Um Hopkins was rated number 4 a week ago, and number 3 a few months ago. Winning fights do not move you out of the P4P lists, especialy very wide wins. Geting hit upside the head by martinez got Williams up the P4P list?

Williams has been top 4 for almost a year. You're dogging him but bigging up Hopkins? Hopkins hasn't fought a ranked fighter in his division since Calzaghe, if that. Since Pavlik he's done nothing, he's clearly shot and his performance last weekend was a complete embarrassment. He's finished. Face the facts.

[crold1]

If there aren't ten fighters better than a 45-year old who took over a year off, came back with Ornelas, and looked THAT bad against Roy (win or not), then boxing has never been worse.

I don't believe that to be true.

[rskumm21]

I don't have a list. These things tend to just turn into a popularity contest.

[BillyBoxing]

so JMM is better than both of the klitchskos? and wtf isnt hopkins in the list, he hasnt aged muched at all and is coming off one of his biggest fights in his career....

Worst,how the **** Pongsalek and Koki Kameda are ranked higer than the Klits.

Mosley and Williams 3 and 4??

WTFFFFFF

Horrible list.And put me Nard out of that ****.

[BillyBoxing]

Skillwise and athletically from p4p sense, the Klitschkos are far inferior fighters to these guys in the top 10. That's true about most heavyweights all time. If there were a heavyweight equivalent of a Manny Pacquiao in the heavyweight division the Klitschkos would get knocked out in 4 or 5 rounds.

Disagree,Wlad is a freak,and P Will is more flawed than him.

[BillyBoxing]

i like the klitchkos but their current competetion is historically ****ty. no way to know how good they truly are, so they don't belong in the top 10 P4P list.

The opposition is ****ty because they make look them ****ty.

When you beat up easily a beast like Peter or talented cat like Chambers.

You are a great fighter,they just are so dominant people think they are beating tomato cans.

[gqjohnb]

The list is pretty good but i think Mosley should be lower since he has been inactive for 15 months. I know guys ducked him but he should have taken fights.

You might be right. I could see how you could put Williams over him but i wouldn't put him below #4.

[gqjohnb]

The opposition is ****ty because they make look them ****ty.

When you beat up easily a beast like Peter or talented cat like Chambers.

You are a great fighter,they just are so dominant people think they are beating tomato cans.

If you can dominate any era you are great in my book but the talent at Heavy weight has definitely diminished in my opinion.

[crold1]

You might be right. I could see how you could put Williams over him but iwould put him below #4.

If he didn't have Mayweather coming up, I'd look different. He does so it can wait until May 1 to re-assess.

[reneg_2]

1.Manny PAC
2.Floyd "Money"
3.Paul Williams
4.JMM
5.Shane Mosley
6.Chad Dawson
7.Celestino Caballero
8.Andre Ward
9.Wladimir Klitschko
10.Ivan Calderon/Miguel Cotto