Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Pullcounter]

What have you done versus what have you done lately?

In deciding how to weigh the various fighters across boxing’s seventeen weight classes there are all sorts of variables taken into account. Ultimately, they often come down to that simple question in determining who should be there at all.
[Click Here To Read More]

pwill is too high on the list.

[gqjohnb]

pwill is too high on the list.

I don't think so Martinez was a quality win. Even though I thought he lost lol

[giacomino]

Pong has gone from slightly underrated to overrated since he got by Kameda. He fought mostly turds during his "record title reign" and Kameda is by far his best win. No way he's suddenly #9 in p4p. Can't see Calderon at #10 either. Especially when the Klitschko brothers are getting no love.

[Dave Rado]

I agree with you on that.

Till Hopkins loses he still P4P caliber. This list is just plain ******ed!!

So he can fight tomato cans with 0-10 records for the next twenty years and remain in your P4P top 10?

It's not a title you win or lose. It's just a hypothetical list of who the best fighters are, making allowance for their weight. And he's no longer one of the best fighters. Dawson would beat him easily.

[Iceta Lives]

This thread is a cluster fuck filled with people with opinionated fan boy posts. Williams deserves to be in the top five because he fights often and the only reason that I could think of having him off the top five is if you think he got dominated by Martinez. Which I don't. He deserves his spot. I don't really like Dawson that much. But his resume warrants being at least close to the top five. I think the list is good for the most part other than Calderon being on there. Alexander should get some consideration too I think.

[ShoulderRoll]

ShoulderRoll-It's really funny how American promoters trying to make the boxer from Philippines an American hero,Idol.Real Americans does not care about Pokemon.I know that.Another reason-Pokemon fighting in States last 5 years. And HBO heeds Stars in the bag, and they made a star from Pokemon.

Are you seriously calling the best fighter on the planet a Pokemon?

That's why no one takes you Klit jockriders seriously. You guys know nothing about good boxing and it shows in every post.

[royjonesjrKTFO]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Chad Dawson
5. Timothy Bradley

Based on skills, abilities, talent, and NOT who is popular or most
impressive recent accomplishments using THE ORIGINAL P4P criteria.

[Spray_resistant]

Its not a bad list but I would put Wlad on and take Calderon out.

[Jim Jeffries]

Paul Williams at #4? Seriously?

Dude has one title that he lost in his first defense, gained it back and then moved up to fight the senior tour.

Most people thought he lost to Martinez, who wasn't anywhere near top 10.