Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[boxing_great]

I beleive that P4P rating is TRASH. It is a virtual thing just like a video game or just a fantasy of autor. Rating must be within SINGLE WEIGHT CLASS.

I agree.
The only 2 definite fighters that should be on there, well 1 really is Pac..
Floyd belongs in there too..Those 2 are the only fighters you can be sure off, the rest is all purely speculation..
Although Floyd of late hasn't been showing why he belongs in there either.

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

dam.....I thought my dude was STILL worthy of a spot in the top dime ......no but seriously, the list is as spot on as ANY I've peeped lately

love the sig brother kidd looks like a future champion to me...Lefty

[BetterCallSaul]

Both Klits ahead of Bradley and Dawson.

[Kayoer]

lfc19titles-How is that? Vladimir destroying everybody. That is how. And don't try to make a ****** excuses like defeats from "joke fighters".
First-every champion has a loses. Second-Pokemon had KO in 3rd round from 11-4-4 journeyman, another KO in 3rd from prospect 18-0. Third-Pokemon had a Draws with bum 31-9-2 and with Marques.

So as you said Pokemon "was knocked out by joke fighters".And this is does not put off Pokemon from 1st place in this ****ty P4P rating

P.S Be real boxing fans Klichko is the Legends, so Paquiao. They three must be in the list.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

LMAO at Williams at #4 and Dawson #5. No Cotto? **** Outta here

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Top 10 P4P
1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Juan Manuel Marquez
4.Shane Mosley
5.Bernard Hopkins
6.Miguel Cotto
7.Ivan Calderon
8.Chad Dawson
9.Hozumi Hazegawa
10.Wladimir Klitschko

[FaustoGeraci]

Top 10 P4P
1.Manny Pacquaio
2.Floyd Mayweather
3.Juan Manuel Marquez
4.Shane Mosley
5.Bernard Hopkins
6.Miguel Cotto
7.Ivan Calderon
8.Chad Dawson
9.Hozumi Hazegawa
10.Wladimir Klitschko

That's garbage. Are you ****in serious? Cotto at 6 and Williams not even in the top 10? This guy is hands down the worst poster around. Cotto is finished, he's not even top 20.

Williams should be number 3, Mosley has one good win against a guy Williams beat and that was over a year ago. Since then Paul has beaten Winky (who handled Mosley twice with ease) and Sergio Martinez. Williams is number 3.

[lfc19titles]

lfc19titles-How is that? Vladimir destroying everybody. That is how. And don't try to make a ****** excuses like defeats from "joke fighters".
First-every champion has a loses. Second-Pokemon had KO in 3rd round from 11-4-4 journeyman, another KO in 3rd from prospect 18-0. Third-Pokemon had a Draws with bum 31-9-2 and with Marques.

So as you said Pokemon "was knocked out by joke fighters".And this is does not put off Pokemon from 1st place in this ****ty P4P rating

P.S Be real boxing fans Klichko is the Legends, so Paquiao. They three must be in the list.

think, you get credit for beating good boxers. they havent defeated good boxers. defeat haye and he will make the top 10, i can promise you that

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

That's garbage. Are you ****in serious? Cotto at 6 and Williams not even in the top 10? This guy is hands down the worst poster around. Cotto is finished, he's not even top 20.

Williams should be number 3, Mosley has one good win against a guy Williams beat and that was over a year ago. Since then Paul has beaten Winky (who handled Mosley twice with ease) and Sergio Martinez. Williams is number 3.

[street bully]

He wins and then drops over 6 places in the P4P list? That's ******ed.