Comments Thread For: Out with the Old (Man): BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Da Hammer]

i like the klitchkos but their current competetion is historically ****ty. no way to know how good they truly are, so they don't belong in the top 10 P4P list.

[Mr. Philadel]

dam.....I thought my dude was STILL worthy of a spot in the top dime ......no but seriously, the list is as spot on as ANY I've peeped lately

[Clegg]

I disagree with placing Williams so high. Dawson is superior to him in most respects IMO.

I think Cotto is deserving of a top 10 place.

I believe that heavyweights should be rated, but I'm in the minority on that one and can see why people feel differently.

Overall it's good stuff, better than the current Ring P4P list.

[Pacdbest]

What have you done versus what have you done lately?

In deciding how to weigh the various fighters across boxing’s seventeen weight classes there are all sorts of variables taken into account. Ultimately, they often come down to that simple question in determining who should be there at all.
[Click Here To Read More]

No Donaire??? You dont see or hear Pongsaklek and Calderon nor hasegawa calling Donaire... These guys even ducks Donaire's ***** Darchinyan.

[Lakas]

B-Hop doesnt deserve to be in the P4P list

[vince_13]

outwiththeold

nonito should be on the topten, to me mosley should be higher than floyd. williams should not be there and vladimir should on the top ten also.

[Kayoer]

I beleive that P4P rating is TRASH. It is a virtual thing just like a video game or just a fantasy of autor. Rating must be within SINGLE WEIGHT CLASS.

[The Loller]

Hiding for two years and then coming back to face a fat lightweight. Yep Floyd should be out of there

[ShoulderRoll]

so JMM is better than both of the klitchskos?

Easily.

Marquez has more well rounded skills as a boxer and has fought a higher quality of opponents. Hell he damn near beat Pacquiao twice.

[Kayoer]

With OLYMPHIC GOLD MEDAL and perfect record 54(48)-3(3)-0 current Heavyweight KING Vladimir Klichko must be undisputed one of the best boxers of current time in any rating. What is wrong?I know what.May be UKRANIAN PASSPORTS?Klichko brothers must be borned in United States to get in this ****TY P4P rating?