So who is the Best Welterweight?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

if cotto and clottey ain't elite , then i've never seen floyd against an elite welterweight either.

.....and mosley hasn't fought an elite welterweight since 2002.

Clottey is not elite and neither was Cotto when Pac fought them IMO. Like I said Im done hating on him Im just being real.

When Marg beat Cotto it made him the The top dog and it was universally recognized on this forum that he was the man. Its not fair to throw that out the window just because Pac gets a few wins.

[Seleção No. 13]

Of course Pac is leading the polls. He just won this weekend. lol. and there are many *******s.

All three welterweights would have to fight each other to truly find out who's on top.

[Schmerzen]

shane hasn't fought in 14 months. mayweather hasn't had a good win since 2007.

is one great win this may enough to trump pacquiao? pacquiao has fought 3 times since mosley's last fight.


quit saying "beat the man" at ww.

there is no "man" at ww since floyd retired.

its not mosleys fault that roach rejected to let pacquiao in the ring with mosley, he was twice in their gym and asked for a fight.
mosley beat margarito and is the best WW until some1 kicks his ass.
i dont care who pacquiao is and how big his fanbase is, he doesnt deserve special treatment.

[Left Banned Tua]

Clottey is not elite and neither was Cotto when Pac fought them IMO. Like I said Im done hating on him Im just being real.

When Marg beating Cotto made him the The top dog and it was universally recognized on this forum that he was the man. Its not fair to through that out the window just because Pac gets a few wins.

that was 14 months ago.

i don't care if you rate mosley #1 at 147.

i see the reason for it.



i just get annoyed by people who say he's #1 but has no reason for it.

if people want to say mosley's recent wins and fights get him the #1 ranking , that's fine.

what i won't allow is people to give dumb reasons like "marg was the man when mosley beat him" , "mosley had wins from 1999-2002" , "mosley beat marg who beat cotto."

rankings are based on skills , recent wins and how you win it.

if you have mosley #1 based on that criteria then i'm fine with it.

[Left Banned Tua]

its not mosleys fault that roach rejected to let pacquiao in the ring with mosley, he was twice in their gym and asked for a fight.
mosley beat margarito and is the best WW until some1 kicks his ass.
i dont care who pacquiao is and how big his fanbase is, he doesnt deserve special treatment.

no one said it was mosley's fault.

but it is what it is. he hasn't fought in 14 months and counting.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

that was 14 months ago.

i don't care if you rate mosley #1 at 147.

i see the reason for it.



i just get annoyed by people who say he's #1 but has no reason for it.

if people want to say mosley's recent wins and fights get him the #1 ranking , that's fine.

what i won't allow is people to give dumb reasons like "marg was the man when mosley beat him" , "mosley had wins from 1999-2002" , "mosley beat marg who beat cotto."

rankings are based on skills , recent wins and how you win it.

if you have mosley #1 based on that criteria then i'm fine with it.

We'll find out soon enough though because these 3 are on a crash course.

[ModernTalking]

Mosley is the man at WW right now. He beat Marg who beat Cotto.

Pacquiao beat Cotto who beat Mosley so what's your point.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Pacquiao beat Cotto who beat Mosley so what's your point.

Cotto beat Mosley in 2007. The winner of May-Mosley decides Number 1 WW IMO.

I cant punish Shane for Berto pulling out a fight.

[Left Banned Tua]

We'll find out soon enough though because these 3 are on a crash course.

actually we only have to wait 'til may.

if mosley wins , he deserves #1 ranking and drop pac to #2.

if mayweather wins , it's possible he can get the #1 but he'd have to be very , very impressive.

[Schmerzen]

no one said it was mosley's fault.

but it is what it is. he hasn't fought in 14 months and counting.

it is what it is, pacquiao could have fought mosley to be the WW-king, but he decided to fight clottey