Who has a greater legacy, Joe Calzaghe or Ronald Wright?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Joe C didnt fight ne1 in their prime or ne1 that wud risk him losing his "0" lets be real. Winky fought all comers Joe C wud have never got in the ring wit Trinidad period....

Why would he? When they were at least 2 weight classes apart

[BEEHOP]

Winky/Ronald Wright easily.

P4P. 2X wins over Mosley is very impressive.

[Allucard]

Shane Mosley is better than any! win Joe Calzahe has, Calzaghe never fought an elite fighter in their prime let alone beat one, he beat B Class fighters and guys who used to be elite who are probably now B class themselves due to deterioration as age has set in.

Hopkins still has elite skills but the fact that his physically cant back that up anymore and has him losing fights to the likes of Taylor suggests he is a B class opponents these days, regardless if he still winning fights that favour him stylistically (Pavlik)

Wink has also beat Trinidad and has a debatable loss to Fernando Vargas.

Joe Calzaghe never proved he was capable of beating an elite! fighter in their prime, his resume is built on wins over solid B/C class fighters and a a debatable decision over a past it Nard Hopkins

Yes, this is right.

[hammerhiem]

If anything Wright does, at least he's still fighting and has proved 10x more than Calslappy ever has.

If by fighting you mean staying inactive for two years and then coming back for a paycheck and getting your ass whooped.

I suppose so.

[Irish Hitman]

calzagheee i think hard to compare

[-Antonio-]

I don't put a lot of weight into beating 154 Mosley or a past it Trinidad. That's just me. Wink probably would have done close to the same against 154 Tito, but he didn't.

I thought he beat Vargas and Taylor in close fights. I guess if he had W's for those fights it'd be a little different.

[SirTomJones]

calzaghe's legacy.. lol
he retired like a year ago and no one knows him already

lol. That is funny when you consider the amount of threads that are still made about him and the number of times he is mentioned.

As for the boxer in your avatar? No one talks about hi

[dans]

I can't believe the poll is this close. I don't even like Calzaghe, but it's obvious he did more than Winky.

[revs1227]

honestly winky right was my fav fighter for 5 yrs his poster is right baove me as i type but i think its silly 2 say hes greater than calzaghe

[sigrab jr]

honestly winky right was my fav fighter for 5 yrs his poster is right baove me as i type but i think its silly 2 say hes greater than calzaghe

Yeah, I voted for Calzaghe. It just doesn't feel right saying Wright has a better legacy than Calzaghe, better names yeah but not a better legacy. At first I was like Calzaghe by miles, then I said wait a minute Wright has more names, but Calzaghe is undefeated and has the 21 title defenses on his resume.