Which is better for Boxing? A Mayweather or Pacquiao win? Poll!

[J.Dempsey]

I think PAC win will b great for boxing,

It'll shock alot of people and prove pacs legacy

mayweather might just get greater, take bigger risks, and have a couple more great fights

[El Castigador]

Personally I think a Pacquiao win would be better. A loss on Mayweather's record would only urge him to take more chances and stop guarding his "0." Also it would truly shake up the rankings and boxing's status quo. Having a truly legitimate #1 fighter who has a style as pleasing as Pacquiao would be tremendous.

Take risks???

So Pac is not the P4P King....did he not just KO his last 4 opponents?

Yet Floyd doesnt take risks...then what the **** is Pac.......Henry Bruseles?

[COACH WEBB]

Take risks???

So Pac is not the P4P King....did he not just KO his last 4 opponents?

Yet Floyd doesnt take risks...then what the **** is Pac.......Henry Bruseles?

I kinda of think that it goes to show that no matter who Floyd fights, he will always been looked at as not taking risks...but I mean, he is about to fight Pac right now but I guess that is not good enough for some ppl.

[COACH WEBB]

Well you can look at a track record and see Pacquiao was the more willing fighter to take dangerous fights. Obviously a great fight from both fighters is ideal for boxing but I believe a new king would do boxing some good.

throw the track record out of the window, they are fighting EACH OTHER now.

[DrewWoodside]

Take risks???

So Pac is not the P4P King....did he not just KO his last 4 opponents?

Yet Floyd doesnt take risks...then what the **** is Pac.......Henry Bruseles?

Of course Pacquiao is the P4P king but he'll gain even greater recognition for that ranking if he manages to beat the former P4P king.

[baracuda]

...excitement is good for boxing....i wonder who brings that between them....lol

[S.G.]

Erm... neither? As long as the right man on the night wins it's great for boxing.

[COACH WEBB]

Of course Pacquiao is the P4P king but he'll gain even greater recognition for that ranking if he manages to beat the former P4P king.

hmmm...I think it goes the other way around Drew.

if the former beats the current, that means a bit more.

"don't you think?"



I love the part on Lion King when Rafiki said that...

[andrewcuff]

I kinda of think that it goes to show that no matter who Floyd fights, he will always been looked at as not taking risks...but I mean, he is about to fight Pac right now but I guess that is not good enough for some ppl.

One fight doesnt make you a risk taker. His P4P reign was laced with "safer" fights than Pacquiao's has been.

[KittenFlaps]

I gotta go with a Pac win being better. He's more of a traditional champion. He seems to garner a broader appeal, bringing in a lot of otherwise uninterested boxing fans.

I think for a die-hard boxing fan either would be great, the fight alone is a gift. But to a casual sports fan, Pacquiao is going to bring in more press and more interest to the sport.