Pacquiao is not GOAT: Coming from a Pacfan

[LeeVanCleef]

I don't think any currently active fighter can be GOAT.

Well, for starters, we've got years. Or decades to decide who is the GOAT.
Let history be the judge of that.

[civicvx]

For me to put Pac top 5 ATG. He would have to beat Floyd, Clottey, Berto, Collazo, Shane @147, Martinez, Dzinziruk, Angulo, Cintron, Spinks P-Will, Foreman @ 154 for me to consider him top 5.

LOL...Floyd is bigger than Pac and he is not even thinking about stepping in the ring with any of those guys and you call him GOAT. PAC beat all those guys and he is only top 5 LOL.

[chinoy]

Im a fan of Pacman but he is not THE Goat....that title belongs to Robinson

[d0n]

What could happen?
Him beating Floyd wont make in the greatest boxer that ever lived.
If he beats Klitschko then i might agree.

It depends on HOW he beats him. KO within the first 3 rounds...? That won't ever be forgotten. Then a KO win over Mosley? Maybe a rematch with JMM back in the lower weights(Pac owns him). Then moving up to LMW and becoming undisputed champion...hehehe. I'm not sure HOW possible all this will be...but its NOT impossible. And if it's done...who knows, many might regard him as the GOAT.

[jrosales13]

U forgot the klitschko brothers too!!.........gawd u got to be kidding me!!......

Bro all A.T.G top 5 I have SRR, Armstrong, Greb, Ali, and Langford. I am sorry beating Floyd, Mosley, P-Will, Foreman, and Martinez does not put him amongst those 5 greats.

[jrosales13]

wtf! pacman is not robot azzhole! and him doing that to be your top 5?

Yes if he does all that he is only top 5. Where does Mosley is not in my top 100, Floyd is not in my top 50, and Martinez, P-Will, Foreman I don't consider great at all... He has to do way more than that to be considered top 5.

[jrosales13]

given his resume, hes easily top ten. hes actually surpassed duran in certain feats. and duran was considered number 5 goat.

i know its not fashionable to put pac highly on the atg list, but give due credit to the man.

Pac is not top 10. I don't even consider Duran top 10 Let alone top 5.. How can you say Pac is easily top 10? Show me your top 10 list right now please...

[fdotorres]

Nice try. Mayweather is already up there with Robbinson and Ali. His skills fool no one. He has faced the best his entire career unlike many haters claim based on his turn down of Margarito. He never LOST A SINGLE FIGHT and dominated EVERY SINGLE opponent he was in a ring with. 40-0 and all championship fights, no catchweights. Another mith was that Marquez was a catchweight. IT WAS ALWAYS A WELTERWEIGHT FIGHT, not a catchweight.

he's a cherry picker

end of story

[jrosales13]

top 30?

Yes top 30. And, that quite a compliment and a hell of an achievement. You know how many great fighters Pac ranks higher than my list? So don't act like I am insulting Pac. Especially since Pac is my favorite active fighters.

[jrosales13]

Nice try. Mayweather is already up there with Robbinson and Ali. His skills fool no one. He has faced the best his entire career unlike many haters claim based on his turn down of Margarito. He never LOST A SINGLE FIGHT and dominated EVERY SINGLE opponent he was in a ring with. 40-0 and all championship fights, no catchweights. Another mith was that Marquez was a catchweight. IT WAS ALWAYS A WELTERWEIGHT FIGHT, not a catchweight.

Please do not insult Robinson and Ali like that...