The GOAT! Pacquiao or Floyd or Crawford?

[SouthpawRight]

To answer your question, he is one of the them. He's not #1 IMO because others resumes/accomplishments overshadow his.

1. Sugar Robinson
2. Harry
3. Henry
4. Sam
5. Ezzard
6. Willie
7. Muhammad
8. Roberto
9. Sugar Leonard
10. Floyd

While there can only be one goat Floyd is up there with the absolute best of them in boxing ability

ATG divisionally; One (Castillo x2)

Jose Luis is all time lightweight?

[SouthpawRight]

In the welterweight division how many natural welterweights did Floyd beat

Floyd beat opps who were ultimately bigger than natural welters

Oscar was 154 champ
Miguel became a 160 champ
Saul became a 175 champ

where manny MARGARITO for the artificial 150 belt

[IronDanHamza]

1. Sugar Robinson
2. Harry
3. Henry
4. Sam
5. Ezzard
6. Willie
7. Muhammad
8. Roberto
9. Sugar Leonard
10. Floyd

While there can only be one goat Floyd is up there with the absolute best of them in boxing ability
Jose Luis is all time lightweight?

I would say so, somewhere between 11-25 I'd have him. He's the Lightweight of his era (early 00's) most definitely.

I think Cliff Rold had him #22.

[djtmal]

Floyd beat opps who were ultimately bigger than natural welters

Oscar was 154 champ
Miguel became a 160 champ
Saul became a 175 champ

where manny MARGARITO for the artificial 150 belt

None of those fighters were natural welterweights

[djtmal]

ATG's in general; One (Canelo)

ATG divisionally; One (Castillo x2)

So two total.



What do you mean by "natural welterweight"?

Neither one is a true all time great imo

[djtmal]

I always feel as if this is a rhetorical question as id imagine anyone would know its zero. But Pac on the other hand must have at least 5 ATG wins.

Its zero but the question will never be answered direct by a Floyd boy.

[IronDanHamza]

Neither one is a true all time great imo

Ok and why would you possibly think I would care about your retarded opinion?

[lefthook2daliva]

The GOAT! Pacquiao or Floyd or Crawford?

They definitely are ATGs (All Time Greats) all 3, but G.O.A.T (Greatest Of All Time)? Makes me suspect that English is not your first language. You lack an understanding of what the words mean.

[SouthpawRight]

None of those fighters were natural welterweights

false Saul started as a welter

Your natural welter mention was intended to say he didn't fight bigger guys

He did and those 3 fights took place beyond welter

Those guys were so big they became champs beyond welter

[djtmal]

false Saul started as a welter

Ok a natural welterweight who had a belt and called him out like Margarito