Comments Thread For: Bill Haney: Devin Is No. 1 P4P; How Much Credit Can We Give Crawford For [Spence] Fight?

[Sheldon312]

You know....... this isn't as black and white as a lot of posters are making it out to be. If we're basing this off of the "version" of Spence vs the "version" of Loma, I think an argument could be made that Haney has the better win. I went back and looked at all of Spence's fights and something was completely off that night, from the ring walk, all the way to his balance. Right now, just being objective, I think Canelo is still P4P 1. Canelo is top 5 in skills and has the best resume.

[Sheldon312]

Not detracting from Devin's achievements, but I haven't got him at #1 in my P4P. Then again, I'm not his Dad.

His win over Loma is better than everyone's in top 10 P4P imo

[ShoulderRoll]

Haney got a gift decision against a natual fw moving up 3 weight classes. FACTS. Bud moved up 3 weight classes to take down the mythical SPENCE. FACTS

It’s becoming clearer that Haney had to drain himself severely to make 135 lbs, yet despite that handicap he was still able to beat Lomachenko.

[satiev1]

it’s becoming clearer that haney had to drain himself severely to make 135 lbs, yet despite that handicap he was still able to beat lomachenko.

lol so he's now a weight bully but when he fought loma he was drained. Lmao.

[ShoulderRoll]

lol so he's now a weight bully but when he fought loma he was drained. Lmao.

Who is saying he was a weight bully? I’m saying he had to severely weaken himself to make 135 lbs.

Yet he was still able to beat Lomachenko in that weakened state.

[JakeTheBoxer]

Haney is a weight bully. Bivol beating much bigger Ramirez is much more impressive than Haney beating small guys.

[Slip jab]

Errol shouldn’t have ducked so long, that’s on him. He was still an undefeated champion at the time he faced Bud. More so, Lopez should rightfully be rated higher, he beat loma when it counted (should’ve been undisputed) than moved up and beat the top 140in JT

[_Rexy_]

You're WELL behind Crawford and Inoue.

[Smash]

Yet he was still able to beat Lomachenko in that weakened state.

how weak was the guy? i mean could he do a push up?

[Smash]

Who is saying he was a weight bully? I’m saying he had to severely weaken himself to make 135 lbs.

Yet he was still able to beat Lomachenko in that weakened state.

“Camp has been great. I’m feeling good. I’m feeling strong. My weight is good. I’m happy and in good spirts. I’m ready to go.”

“When we go into a fight, it’s a war. It’s combat. Two warriors going at it. We put our life on the line when we go in that ring.”

https://www.toprank.com/all-news/und...-garden-arena/

ops