Is it a KO? or Not?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JAB5239
    Dallas Cowboys
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Dec 2007
    • 28300
    • 5,349
    • 4,522
    • 73,018

    #51
    Originally posted by Mr._Pink
    then how come they called it a ko in liston-ali 2?
    That was a hatchet job by the referee, Jersey Joe Walcott. After Ali had dropped Liston Ali was standing over Sonny telling him to get up and Walcott could not get him to a neutral corner. After finally getting him there he was either counting or on his way to count (don't remember) when Nat Fleischer called him over and said the fight was over because Liston had been down longer than a 10 count. Walcott than waived the fight off. Why he listened to Fleischer is anybodies guess since Nat wasn't in any way affiliated with the fight except as Ring magazines editor. Its my opinion Walcott dropped the ball in that fight. Liston was never given a full count and did what any hurt fighter would do and waited for one to begin. I don't think he would have won either way, but he deserved the opportunity to be given a count to see if he would have gotten up.

    Comment

    • gopi11
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Oct 2006
      • 3731
      • 174
      • 210
      • 10,160

      #52
      Originally posted by miron_lang
      Tarvers KO of Roy and KT over Judah looks very fast. I even think Roy could have beat the count. but that looks so much faster than this one.

      what i want to know is how should the ref count it? a regular 10 secs can be a count of 8 or a count of 12 for a referee. whats the rule? its all on the ref's discretion?

      A boxing count should be in English, specially if the fight was held in America and the boxers competing are both foreigners. There's only one syllable for each number from 1 to 10 on the English language except the 7, while there's 2 syllables for 7 out of those 10 numbers in Spanish, it might not mean much, but it only needs a second difference between a KD and a KO.

      If by a some strange twist of fate Marquez scored a KD on Pacquiao, will Cortez count in Tagalog too for fairness sake? For the uninitiated, 9 out of the 10 numbers have two syllables in Tagalog, except for the number 2, it has 3 syllables.

      Musta na 'pre?

      Comment

      • gopi11
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Oct 2006
        • 3731
        • 174
        • 210
        • 10,160

        #53
        Originally posted by kadyo
        I remember the time rolando navarette was knocked down by choi chung il when they fought in the Philippines. I counted using a timer that navarette was down on the floor and it was 17 seconds. Navarette got up to win the fight by decision.


        I was at the fight prof, it was a KO by Navarette on the 11th, iirc...

        Comment

        • JAB5239
          Dallas Cowboys
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Dec 2007
          • 28300
          • 5,349
          • 4,522
          • 73,018

          #54
          Originally posted by JAB5239
          He'll be banned soon enough my friend.
          I <3 Boxing
          Banned

          It didn't take Nostradamus to see this coming. Good riddance.

          Comment

          • JAB5239
            Dallas Cowboys
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Dec 2007
            • 28300
            • 5,349
            • 4,522
            • 73,018

            #55
            Originally posted by gopi11
            A boxing count should be in English, specially if the fight was held in America and the boxers competing are both foreigners. There's only one syllable for each number from 1 to 10 on the English language except the 7, while there's 2 syllables for 7 out of those 10 numbers in Spanish, it might not mean much, but it only needs a second difference between a KD and a KO.

            If by a some strange twist of fate Marquez scored a KD on Pacquiao, will Cortez count in Tagalog too for fairness sake? For the uninitiated, 9 out of the 10 numbers have two syllables in Tagalog, except for the number 2, it has 3 syllables.

            Musta na 'pre?
            Wasn't sure what I was going to think of this post after the first sentence, but its actually very interesting and something I never took into consideration before.

            Comment

            • gopi11
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Oct 2006
              • 3731
              • 174
              • 210
              • 10,160

              #56
              Originally posted by JAB5239
              Wasn't sure what I was going to think of this post after the first sentence, but its actually very interesting and something I never took into consideration before.

              My pleasure, and it's probably because I can count in English, Spanish and Tagalog, any subtle differences from counting is very noticable to me and could spell the difference between a KO, or a draw, in the case of the Pac/Marquez I.

              About the Ali/Liston II, there were rumors that Liston had mob ties back then, it wasn't proven though because there were no paper trails and a snitch back in the 60s won't get to live a day longer to give his story. Liston used to train at the Thunderbird Casino, which is known to be run by a New York mob (Ashe Resnick)...

              Comment

              • JAB5239
                Dallas Cowboys
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Dec 2007
                • 28300
                • 5,349
                • 4,522
                • 73,018

                #57
                Originally posted by gopi11
                My pleasure, and it's probably because I can count in English, Spanish and Tagalog, any subtle differences from counting is very noticable to me and could spell the difference between a KO, or a draw, in the case of the Pac/Marquez I.

                About the Ali/Liston II, there were rumors that Liston had mob ties back then, it wasn't proven though because there were no paper trails and a snitch back in the 60s won't get to live a day longer to give his story. Liston used to train at the Thunderbird Casino, which is known to be run by a New York mob (Ashe Resnick)...
                Liston had ties to organized crime. In 1952, after serving two years in prison, he was paroled to a team of boxing handlers with ties to John Vitale, a St. Louis underworld figure. Six years later, Frankie Carbo and Blinky Palermo, top Mafia figures in the Northeast, became the majority owner of Liston's contract. Carbo was later indicted on conspiracy, multiple counts of undercover management of prizefighters and unlicensed matchmaking. Liston fought 12 fights under their control.

                By the time of the Ali fights Liston's ties with organized crime were gone. Im sure he was still acquainted with some of them, but they were no longer part of his boxing career as far as I know.

                Comment

                • gopi11
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Oct 2006
                  • 3731
                  • 174
                  • 210
                  • 10,160

                  #58
                  Originally posted by JAB5239
                  Liston had ties to organized crime. In 1952, after serving two years in prison, he was paroled to a team of boxing handlers with ties to John Vitale, a St. Louis underworld figure. Six years later, Frankie Carbo and Blinky Palermo, top Mafia figures in the Northeast, became the majority owner of Liston's contract. Carbo was later indicted on conspiracy, multiple counts of undercover management of prizefighters and unlicensed matchmaking. Liston fought 12 fights under their control.

                  By the time of the Ali fights Liston's ties with organized crime were gone. Im sure he was still acquainted with some of them, but they were no longer part of his boxing career as far as I know.

                  Thnx for the heads up!

                  I always think of Liston whenever I catch the movie, "Snake Eyes", now I know why!

                  Comment

                  • WhoreUs
                    Banned
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Oct 2008
                    • 15770
                    • 556
                    • 606
                    • 20,363

                    #59
                    Originally posted by JAB5239
                    That was a hatchet job by the referee, Jersey Joe Walcott. After Ali had dropped Liston Ali was standing over Sonny telling him to get up and Walcott could not get him to a neutral corner. After finally getting him there he was either counting or on his way to count (don't remember) when Nat Fleischer called him over and said the fight was over because Liston had been down longer than a 10 count. Walcott than waived the fight off. Why he listened to Fleischer is anybodies guess since Nat wasn't in any way affiliated with the fight except as Ring magazines editor. Its my opinion Walcott dropped the ball in that fight. Liston was never given a full count and did what any hurt fighter would do and waited for one to begin. I don't think he would have won either way, but he deserved the opportunity to be given a count to see if he would have gotten up.
                    joe screwed up.

                    sonny did the right thing. he's not suppost to get up 'til the ref counts to around 7 or 8.

                    since joe didn't count......not fair to liston.

                    oh well......sonny probably took a dive anyway.

                    Comment

                    • JAB5239
                      Dallas Cowboys
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 28300
                      • 5,349
                      • 4,522
                      • 73,018

                      #60
                      Originally posted by Mr._Pink
                      joe screwed up.

                      sonny did the right thing. he's not suppost to get up 'til the ref counts to around 7 or 8.

                      since joe didn't count......not fair to liston.

                      oh well......sonny probably took a dive anyway.


                      Lol, that a whole other discussion my friend.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP