Calzaghe is a shoe in ATG.

[IMDAZED]

His record had a zero in the loss column. What the hell are you talking about?

If you're going to make a point, do it. Undefeated record is an accomplishment but there's a reason why most of the greats don't have one. Unless, of course, you put Calzaghe into the Robinson/Duran stratosphere.

[djtmal]

much respect to joe calzaghe for coming to america and staking his claim as truly one of the best of his era...i was impressed by how he legitly outpointed nard hopkins and retire as champ...

[sammiza567]

i'd put him somewhere in the 100-150 range. if you think he is an atg take a step back and realize how all over his nuts you really are...truth hurts.

[BattlingNelson]

His record had a zero in the loss column. What the hell are you talking about?

So does Sven Ottke.

[sammiza567]

Who was out there that he didn't fight that he should of?

roy jones jr....b-hop....he didnt fight either of them.

[Iceta]

Calzaghe had a chance to solidify his legacy when he broke free from Frank Warren and he blew it. He deserves all the negative flack he gets. Calzaghe has retired when things have gotten interesting.

[sweetpea87]

Shoe in Hall of Famer. All time great is possible.

[theghost#1]

I think he's an ATG. The dude never lost and defended his title 21times.

[Abstraction]

Sorry, but anyone with a ounce of Boxing knowledge know's that his career is a joke.

Question Marks everywhere.

I dont rate someone who's biggest wins are Lacy and Kessler.

Oh, and a dodgy SD against a 43 year old.

If you want to make a big deal of being undefeated, i take Ottke is another Boxing superstar?

[Spacey1991]

He is a HOFer definitley, I aint sure about ATG... he would be close to top 100 but I aint sure if he quite breaks it... maybe he does but if he does it is at the lower end of the top 100.