Calzaghe is a shoe in ATG.

[Easy-E]

That's because you're very prejudiced against white boxers. You've never posted a single positive comment about one that I've ever seen.

You're opinion of Joe Calzaghe is like a KKK member's opinion of Sugar Ray Robinson, so we can't take it seriously.

I am white. I have said many positives about white fighters, from Hatton to Pavlik to Vitali.
I think Joe is a HOF, just not an ATG.

I base my opinions of boxers and their abilities on something OTHER than race.
Unlike you.
Using that logic, you in fact, are the racist.

[jpitt]

I don't get why people fight B-Hop. You win, it's because he's old, if it's close he was robbed and if he won well it's because B-Hop is so good in his 40s!

BHop in a nutshell. Great point.

[jpitt]

calzaghe in my eyes isn't an atg
hell he shouldnt even make it in hof
but thats just my opinion

Shouldn't be in the HOF, huh? You're a blithering idiot.

[daggum]

atg huh?

[IMG]http://i112.***********.com/albums/n187/Detox_bucket/hopcalz-1.gif[/IMG]

[Pullcounter]

Yeah he fought a lot of his fights at home. So what? He beat Bhop Kessler Roy and the smoke screen Jeff Lacy. He beat two ATG so who did he skip and Why doesnt he deserve retire with the respect of boxing fans everywhere even here in hater heaven?

yeah, shoe in for top 100 to 200.

[studentofthegam]

If he is an ATG you, Joe, and the rest of his fans wouldn't have to proclaim to us that he is.

Be thorough and say why he doesnt deserve it. I dont particularly care for Joe Louis' style but he was a winner and good at the way he did his thing. I was never high on DLH but he consistently won and faced good opponents. I dont think Hatton is a very good boxer skill-wise but he fought good comp and won 40 fights so I wont attack his fans for giving him an ATG nod. Well unless they diss one of my favs. U see the pattern Im making. Rhyme and reason.

[studentofthegam]

yeah, shoe in for top 100 to 200.

If you ask me there are not many that have or ever will make as good of an exit as joe. I bet you can barely name 200 boxers let alone 100 that are better than Joe.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

Jimmy Wilde>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Joe Calzaghe.

[one-Punch]

Calzaghe is definitely an all-time great

anybody who thinks otherwise is a racist

I guess I am racist then. I think if you are to become an ATG, you have to fight. The way I see it, Calzaghe took the easy way out. A lot of boxers dread the day they loose their first fight, and I think this is Calzaghes greatest fear. If Calzaghe really wanted to become an ATG, he should of jumped some weight classes and took some chances.

[Pullcounter]

If you ask me there are not many that have or ever will make as good of an exit as joe. I bet you can barely name 200 boxers let alone 100 that are better than Joe.

yeah, that's something for historians to do, but boxing has a long history. calz is overated and not that great.