A win for cotto means #1 pound for pound?

[fdotorres]

He beat a Baldomir who was undisputed champion at that time
destroyed Judah who was an elite fighter (Floyd is the one who destroyed Judah)
Went up to 154 to beat a WBC champ
The ring magazine Champ went up to 147 and lost,so what more can you say?

the ring magazine champ had already moved up and lost to collazo, but got a gift decision

he beat bumdomir

he beat the guy who lost to bumdomir, but not destroyed him. showing your bias once again it seems

the DLH fight was really the only one i'd give tons of credit, but he didn't dominate him (won by SD)

pac overshadowed floyd with his wins against DLH and hatton. is it fair? 50% of it is, but that's life. p4p, pac >>>>>> floyd, move on

[JM1]

Is that how you define convincing?
In any case how many years back was that?
So in your eyes Cotto shouldnt be an underdog because he had a questionable decision over Mosley 10 yrs ago?The fact that he was made into a punchbag by Margarito in his next fight after the gift is immaterial?

look at this ****** post. didnt you fail to comprehend?

[JM1]

the ring magazine champ had already moved up and lost to collazo, but got a gift decision

he beat bumdomir

he beat the guy who lost to bumdomir, but not destroyed him. showing your bias once again it seems

the DLH fight was really the only one i'd give tons of credit, but he didn't dominate him (won by SD)

pac overshadowed floyd with his wins against DLH and hatton. is it fair? 50% of it is, but that's life. p4p, pac >>>>>> floyd, move on

the hardest people to deal with are the floyd ball suckers. look at his post calling me ****** when its him who failed to comprehend

[oc9979]

He beat a Baldomir who was undisputed champion at that time
destroyed Judah who was an elite fighter (Floyd is the one who destroyed Judah)
Went up to 154 to beat a WBC champ
The ring magazine Champ went up to 147 and lost,so what more can you say?

what fight were you watching??
Destroyed Judah??
You could say that Kostya Tszyu destroyed Judah.
Cotto destroyed Judah.

[JM1]

what fight were you watching??
Destroyed Judah??
You could say that Kostya Tszyu destroyed Judah.
Cotto destroyed Judah.

i was about to quote that. and that ball sucker have the guts to ask me if i watch boxing

[fdotorres]

i was about to quote that. what a pathetic poster

the funny thing is that he says that "floyd destroyed judah", then reaffirms it by writing between parenthesis "floyd was the one who destroyed him"

it's like even he doesn't believe what he says, but keeps trying so hard

[JM1]

the funny thing is that he says that "floyd destroyed judah", then reaffirms it by writing between parenthesis "floyd was the one who destroyed him"

it's like even he doesn't believe what he says, but keeps trying so hard

and he have the guts to call me ******. he failed to comprehend to my post and thinks im ****** cause i said pac being the 3-1 favorite is too much. troll got owned and i feel like giving him some red K drive by. hes not coming back i think

[yvhes1104]

I think Cotto still needs to fight at different weight classes to be considered top p4p. Look at the top 4. Pacquiao, Marquez, Hopkins, Mosley... Manny can fight from 130, 135, 140 and 147. Marquez 130, 135 and now first timer at 147, Hopkins 170-175, Mosley, 147-154.

Cotto needs to try 154 and beat a natural junior middleweight. to be considered top p4p... at least for me...

[PowerpuG]

I think Cotto still needs to fight at different weight classes to be considered top p4p. Look at the top 4. Pacquiao, Marquez, Hopkins, Mosley... Manny can fight from 130, 135, 140 and 147. Marquez 130, 135 and now first timer at 147, Hopkins 170-175, Mosley, 147-154.

Cotto needs to try 154 and beat a natural junior middleweight. to be considered top p4p... at least for me...

Look, all respect to pacquiao and jmm..they deserve top spots.. but no (Oscar bro?) and no

[JM1]

fanboy's rep is now red. why is that?