Please answer with all hate aside.

[BennyST]

Remember I said hate aside. We dont need to discuss hate topics like PPV, race backing and disrespecting JMM.
Now back to boxing. OOOOOKKKKKK, as a hater didnt you think he was pushin it a little goin up to fight DLH and Baldomir. Let me guess, You also think Judah was whippin Floyds ass too. Just a guess. Did he not punish all those guys. If I recall correctly did DLH beat a washed up JCC and get full credit for it? One more question before I go, In that warped angry mind of yours maybe you can tell me the truth, could Floyd beat Meldric Taylor. I want to know because he was less than five seconds from beating JCC.

Let me just say this one thing. You think it was pushing it that Mayweather moved up from SFW or 130 and then beat an old, close to shot Oscar and a bad champ in Judah and Baldomir at WW?

Do you even realise that Duran started at what would be Super Bantamweight or 118, moved up and beat Ernesto Marcel, then won the lightweight title and unified against HOfer Ken Buchanan, then jumped 140 and moved straight to WW to fight one of the top three ATG WW's in Leonard and beat him? A guy that was much bigger and much younger? How does that compare to what Maywether did? It doesn't. Duran stomps those accomplishments.

[talip bin osman]

I have looked at a few atg lists and I see some names that are consistently in the top 25 to 30.
-Duran
-Pep
-Chavez Sr.
Im not picking on them because they are not the only ones. But really, doesnt Mayweather mop the floor with these guys. Lets take that down a notch. Thats my personal opinion. OK doesnt he beat all three.

hypothetically mopping the floor with the 3 great fighters u mentioned as a sole criteria for higher places in any ATG list would not cut it for PBF...

[ThunderWolf]

I have looked at a few atg lists and I see some names that are consistently in the top 25 to 30.
-Duran
-Pep
-Chavez Sr.
Im not picking on them because they are not the only ones. But really, doesnt Mayweather mop the floor with these guys. Lets take that down a notch. Thats my personal opinion. OK doesnt he beat all three.

Mayweather Jr. is not even in the top 50 atg and that`s a fact.

[koboy]

Floyd's legend is built on skill, not actual accomplishment.

Best post in awhile. Green K for you.

[joseph5620]

Mayweather Jr. is not even in the top 50 atg and that`s a fact.

Actually it's not unless you can come up with 50 better fighters.

[ThunderWolf]

Actually it's not unless you can come up with 50 better fighters.

Maybe you can just update this list :

In 2002, Ring Magazine published a list of the 80 Best Fighters of the Last 80 Years in boxing, as voted by the magazine's writers.

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Muhammad Ali
Joe Louis
Roberto Duran
Willie Pep
Harry Greb
Benny Leonard
Sugar Ray Leonard
Pernell Whitaker
Carlos Monzon
Rocky Marciano
Ezzard Charles
Archie Moore
Sandy Saddler
Jack Dempsey
Marvin Hagler
Julio Cesar Chavez
Eder Jofre
Alexis Arguello
Barney Ross
Evander Holyfield
Ike Williams
Salvador Sanchez
George Foreman
Kid Gavilan
Larry Holmes
Mickey Walker
Ruben Olivares
Gene Tunney
**** Tiger
Fighting Harada
Emile Griffith
Tony Canzoneri
Aaron Pryor
Pascual Perez
Miguel Canto
Manuel Ortiz
Charley Burley
Carmen Basilio
Michael Spinks
Joe Frazier
Khaosai Galaxy
Roy Jones, Jr.
Tiger Flowers
Panama Al Brown
Kid Chocolate
Joe Brown
Tommy Loughran
Bernard Hopkins
Felix Trinidad
Jake LaMotta
Lennox Lewis
Wilfredo Gomez
Bob Foster
Jose Napoles
Billy Conn
Jimmy McLarnin
Pancho Villa
Carlos Ortiz
Bob Montgomery
Freddie Miller
Benny Lynch
Beau Jack
Azumah Nelson
Eusebio Pedroza
Thomas Hearns
Wilfred Benitez
Antonio Cervantes
Ricardo Lopez
Sonny Liston
Mike Tyson
Vicente Saldivar
Gene Fullmer
Oscar De La Hoya
Carlos Zarate
Marcel Cerdan
Flash Elorde
Mike McCallum
Harold Johnson

So can PBF even best Marvin Hagler in this list?

[AllyboyJNR]

Mayweather beats Duran at 135 easily.
Chavez Sr was pretty big so I'd give him a good shot against Floyd. p4p Floyd was better, although his resume isn't.
I haven't seen many Pep fights so I wouldn't know.

ur telling me chavez had a better resume lol look at his 80 odd fights before he started losing....he was a known cherrypicker who should av lost to meldrick taylor

[IMDAZED]

ur telling me chavez had a better resume lol look at his 80 odd fights before he started losing....he was a known cherrypicker who should av lost to meldrick taylor

Chavez was a known cherry picker? No fool, he was known as the best fighter in the world.

WTF drug are some of these people on???

[studentofthegam]

what makes you think floyd would even step in the ring with them?

Because he whipped everyone he's faced Mr. Gacy

[KittenFlaps]

Mayweather is no Leonard. Duran mops the floor with him.

I am an admitted Duran nuthugger though.